Chapter 1: THE MAN WHO HIRED MY HANDS0% read • ~9 min

Chapter 1

THE MAN WHO HIRED MY HANDS

9 min read•1,891 words

I was halfway through telling a man that his wife would never forgive him when the shop bell rang and the whole afternoon went quiet.

I did not turn around. I knew that bell. It had a rattle in its throat that only certain doors could set off, and only certain people opened them the way he did, slowly, as if he expected the building to object.

“Miss Vale?” Mr. Pruitt said. “You were saying.”

“I was saying that you shouldn’t open with an excuse.” My voice came out level. I was proud of that. “Forty years, and you start with because. Start with I was wrong.”

“But I wasn’t wrong. Not entirely.”

“Then she won’t read past the first line.”

He sagged in the wicker chair, seventy-something and rumpled and desperate, holding his hat in both hands like a collection plate. Behind me, the floorboards took a step. Then another. A smell reached me, cedar and cold salt and diesel, and my pen bled a small black flower into the margin of the page.

“Nora.”

One word. Seven years, and he still put the weight on the second syllable, like he was setting something down carefully.

I capped the pen. I turned around.

Eli Hartwell stood between the greeting card rack and the shelf of wax seals, and the first thing I thought, God help me, was that he looked tired. Not older. Tired, in the bones. He had lost weight he could not afford to lose. Gray had come in at his temples. The scar through his left eyebrow was the same, and the crooked front tooth, and the way his right hand lived in his coat pocket, turning something over and over.

The compass. His father’s.

“Mr. Pruitt,” I said, “I’ll have a draft for you Thursday.”

“Is everything all right?”

“Thursday,” I said, and something in my face must have helped him decide. He took his hat and went. The bell rattled again. Eli did not move out of its way, and Mr. Pruitt had to turn sideways to pass him, and the door closed on the fog.

The shop smelled of paper and old glue and the lavender Aunt Dot burned to hide the radiator. It had never felt small before.

“You cut your hair,” Eli said.

“You’re going to open with my hair?”

“I didn’t know how to open.”

“Mr. Pruitt could give you notes.” I picked up my tea. It was cold. I drank it anyway, because it gave my hands something to do. “Start with I was wrong. Works nine times out of ten.”

He almost smiled. It cost him something, I saw. “I’m not here to say that.”

“No?”

“Not yet.”

Not yet. I set the cup down very carefully on the blotter.

“I’m here to hire you,” he said.

I laughed. It was not a good laugh. “I’m sorry?”

“Your sign says custom letters, vows, and speeches.” He nodded at the window, where I had painted the words myself, in gold, four years ago, on a morning I wanted very badly to be busy. “I need vows written.”

“For who?”

“For me.”

The radiator ticked. Out on the harbor a bell buoy gave its long, wet moan.

“You’re getting married,” I said.

“In six weeks.”

I want to tell you I said something cutting. That I had rehearsed it over seven years, that I had a speech sharpened and ready, and that I delivered it standing straight with my chin up. What I actually did was look at his hands, at the left one, the bare one, the one that had once been mine to hold, and think very clearly: he does not have a ring yet.

“Congratulations,” I said.

“Nora.”

“No, truly. That’s wonderful. People always say they want a fresh start.” I started squaring a stack of cream cardstock that was already square. “There’s a woman in Rockland who does vows. She’s good. Very traditional. I can give you her card.”

“I don’t want Rockland.”

“Well, I don’t want this.”

“I know.” He said it quietly. He came a step closer, and I smelled the cold on his coat, and my whole body leaned the wrong way before I caught it. “I know you don’t. I’d think less of you if you did.”

“Then why are you standing in my shop?”

“Because I’ve tried to write them myself.” He took his hand from his pocket and, with it, a folded square of lined paper gone soft at the creases. “Eleven times. Every one sounds like a man reading a card at a funeral.”

“That’s a genre.”

“It’s not mine.”

“You don’t have a genre, Eli. You had a way of going quiet until the room did what you wanted. And then you left it.”

That one landed. His jaw moved. A muscle jumped under the stubble, and I felt the small, mean thrill of it and hated myself for that exactly as much as I hated him.

“You’re the only person alive,” he said, “who knows how I sound when I mean it.”

“You didn’t mean it when you left.”

“I meant that more than anything I’ve ever done.”

The shop went still. Even the radiator seemed to hold its breath. I pressed my thumbnail into my index finger, hard, the old trick, and the little bright pain steadied me.

“Then you know where the door is,” I said.

He did not move toward it. He unfolded the paper instead and laid it on my counter, between the wax seals and the cold tea, the way you set down something that might go off.

“Notes,” he said. “On her. Things I’d want said, if I could say them. You don’t have to touch it. You don’t have to say yes. I’m at the Harbor Inn, room four, until Sunday.”

“You can stay at the Harbor Inn for a year and the answer will be the same.”

“Probably.” He looked at me then. Really looked, with those pale, tired eyes, and I felt seven years go thin as tissue. “But I had to ask you first. Before anyone else wrote my words. It had to be you.”

“Why?”

He had his father’s compass out again. His thumb passed over the glass, once, twice.

“Because you’d tell me if it wasn’t true.”

He left. The bell rattled. The fog took him in two steps.

I stood there with my hand flat on the counter, very still, the way you stand after a car crash, waiting to find out what hurts.

“Well,” said Aunt Dot, from the doorway of the back room. “That took longer than I thought.”

She had not been there a moment ago. Or she had, and I had been too busy being brave to notice. She stood with a roll of kraft paper under one arm, her silver braid over her shoulder, her reading glasses swinging on their chain. Her face told me nothing. It never did. Forty years of sorting paper had taught her exactly how much to fold.

“You knew he was back,” I said.

“I knew he’d been to see me.”

“When?”

“Tuesday.”

“Tuesday.” I could hear my own voice climbing. “It’s Monday. Dot. It’s Monday.”

“Last Tuesday.”

“You let me sit here for six days writing divorce letters and condolences and thank-you cards for a funeral lunch, and you didn’t think to say, Nora, by the way, the man who ruined your life is back in town?”

“He asked me not to.”

“And you said yes?”

“I said I’d think about it.” She set the kraft paper down on the table with unusual care. “I thought about it for six days. You’ll notice I’m still here.”

“That isn’t an answer.”

“No,” Dot said. “It isn’t.”

She went back into the stockroom. I heard her start to hum, some hymn I half knew, and I understood that this was as close to an apology as I would get tonight, and that it came with a lock on it.

I closed the shop at five. I turned the sign. I did the till twice because I got the total wrong the first time, and I walked home along the seawall with the fog sitting on my shoulders and the harbor lights doubling in the black water, and I did not look in at the Harbor Inn. I did not even slow down. I’m only telling you that so you will understand how hard I did not look.

My apartment was above the bakery. Theo had left a bag on my doorknob, still warm, a note stuck to it in his crooked capitals: SAW A GHOST OUT THE WINDOW. THOUGHT YOU MIGHT NEED A CINNAMON ROLL. I stood on the landing and ate half of it standing up, and I didn’t taste it.

Then I made fresh tea, because the old habit said I must, and sat at the kitchen table, and took the folded paper from the pocket of my coat.

I had not meant to bring it home. I want that on the record. I told myself I had only wanted it off my counter, away from my customers, out of sight. I told myself I would throw it in the stove.

I unfolded it.

His handwriting had not changed. Square, blunt capitals, pressed hard enough to dent the page. Thirty lines, maybe, no order to them. A man emptying his pockets onto a table.

She laughs at the wrong parts of movies, I read. Always a half second early, like she’s trying to beat the joke.

She hums when she lies. Doesn’t know she does it.

She hates lilacs. Carries them anyway.

She leaves the porch light on for people who aren’t coming back.

My cup stopped halfway to my mouth.

It was not a strange line. Lots of women leave lights on. Lots of porches in Marrow Cove had one burning right now, a hundred small gold coins in the fog. But I knew a girl who hummed when she lied. I knew a girl who held lilacs with her nose wrinkled up like they’d insulted her mother. I knew a girl who had laughed at the wrong parts of every movie we ever watched together, curled against my side on the couch with her feet in my lap, always a half second early.

No. I put the cup down. It rattled in the saucer.

No. Lots of people hum. Lots of people hate flowers. I was tired, and angry, and seven years hungry for any sign that he had thought of me at all, and I was seeing a face in every cloud. That was all this was.

I turned the paper over.

On the back, down at the very bottom, in a tiny cramped hand, as if he had written it and then thought better of it and wanted it small enough to ignore, there was a single letter and a period.

W.

My phone buzzed on the table.

An unknown number. A text. I did not pick it up. I did not need to. The preview slid up on the lit screen and I read it from where I sat, with my heart going slow and heavy like something being dragged along the bottom of the harbor.

Hi, big sister. Please don’t be mad. I should have told you myself.