Chapter 2
LILACS IN NOVEMBER
I typed fourteen replies to my sister and deleted every one.
Okay is a lie. Why now is an accusation. Where have you been for seven years is a question, and I had not decided yet whether I wanted the answer. The cursor blinked at the end of each failed sentence like a small, patient heartbeat.
Please don’t be mad. As if mad were a weather system, and not a house I had been living in since I was twenty-four.
I picked up the phone to call Theo. That was the plan. Theo would say something ridiculous about croissants, and I would laugh against my will, and the night would turn back into a night I could stand. His name was right there in my favorites.
My thumb went to the unknown number instead.
Wren picked up before the first ring finished. “Nora.” Her voice had not changed. It still sounded like someone running toward you with an armful of something she was about to drop. “Oh, love. Look out your window.”
I did not want to. I went anyway. The glass was cold and beaded with fog, and at the far end of Gull Lane, under the one streetlamp the town council could not be talked into replacing, a small silver car sat with its hazards blinking. A pale shape behind the wheel. A hand raised, palm out, fingers spread, the way you wave at someone across a very wide river.
“You’re here,” I said.
“Since four. I’ve been parked outside St. Brendan’s for three hours working up to it. Then Eli texted that he’d been to see you, and I thought, well, you’ve lost your nerve and your head start, Wren, so you may as well stop dithering.”
“You’ve been in my town for four hours.”
“It’s still half mine.”
“It’s about a quarter,” I said, “and you left the deed on the kitchen table.”
She laughed, a startled, wet little sound, and hung up.
I took my coat. I did not take my shoes off the stairs fast enough, and I nearly went down the last three, and at the bottom the back door of the bakery was propped open with a flour sack. Theo stood in the light of the proofing room with dough to his elbows, and he looked at my face for exactly one second.
“Don’t,” I said.
“I wasn’t going to.”
“You were going to say something about butter.”
“I was going to say the back door stays open.” He turned a round of dough with the heel of his hand, slow and steady. “You know that. Whatever it is. Back door’s open.”
I could not answer. I went out into the fog with that sentence warm on my back like a hand.
The car smelled of rental upholstery and something green and bruised. Lilacs. A bunch of them lay across the dashboard in crackling cellophane, purple and pale against the dark windshield, in November, in Maine, which meant they had been flown in from somewhere that did not know what season it was.
I got in. I shut the door. We sat.
Wren had cut her hair. It fell to her chin now, still gold, still catching every scrap of light as though it were owed. She wore a gray wool hat pulled low and a coat that cost more than my rent. Up close, there were small shadows under her eyes, and a new line beside her mouth that had not come from smiling. She looked at me with my own eyes in a softer face, and I thought: she is twenty-eight. She was twenty-one when she left. I missed seven years of her face.
“You look good,” she said.
“I look like I’ve been ironed.”
“You look like you.” She wrapped both hands around the steering wheel. “I had a speech. It was very good. I rehearsed it in the mirror of a Dunkin’ in Portsmouth.”
“Let’s hear it.”
“I’ve forgotten all of it.”
“Then start with the end.”
She took a breath. Her hands tightened. “Eli and I are getting married.”
It is a strange thing, to hear a sentence you already know. It does not land. It simply confirms the shape of a hole. I watched the lilacs shiver in their cellophane as a truck went by on the seawall road, and I said, because I am a coward and I am dry as a bone when I am hurt, “Congratulations. He said six weeks.”
“Nora.”
“I’m happy for you. Truly. I’ll bring a toaster.”
“Don’t do that.”
“What would you like me to do? Weep? I could probably manage something. It’s been a long day.”
“I’d like you to hit me.” Her voice cracked down the middle. “I’d like you to hit me, and then I’d like you to let me explain.”
“I’ve never hit anyone in my life.”
“You pinched me in the church basement once. Second grade. I have a scar.”
“You ate my entire communion wafer.”
“It was a very good wafer.”
And there it was, the thing I could not afford. A laugh came up from somewhere under my ribs, ugly and unwilling, and I put my hand over my mouth. Wren heard it, and her whole face broke open with relief, and I hated that too. She still knew exactly where to press.
“How?” I said, when I could speak. “Where? Do not tell me it was a romantic comedy.”
“Boston. Three years ago.” She picked at the cellophane on the lilacs. “I work in a flower shop on Charles Street. Do not laugh.”
“You hate flowers.”
“I hate the smell. I like the look. It’s a long story, I’m good at it, ask me about the peonies sometime.” She paused. “He came in one February for something for his landlady. Stood there in the doorway like a man reading a bus schedule in a foreign language. And I thought, I know that stance. I know that shoulder. And he looked at me, and he went very white.”
“I’m sure he did.”
“We didn’t speak for twenty minutes. I wrapped his flowers. I took his money. And then he asked if I’d have a coffee, and I said I was working, and he said he’d wait.”
“He’s good at that.”
“He is,” she said softly. “It’s one of the worst things about him.”
The fog pressed against the windshield. Somewhere out on the water the bell buoy tolled, and I counted its slow, dragging beats until I could trust my voice.
“You left three days after he did,” I said. “Seven years ago. I thought you couldn’t stand to watch me fall apart. I thought that was why you went.”
Wren’s eyes slid to the dashboard. “That’s one way to put it.”
“Is there another?”
“There’s a long one.” She tried a smile. It did not hold. “I’ll tell you all of it. I promise. Just not tonight, not in a car, not with you looking at me like I’m a ledger that doesn’t add up.”
“That’s not how I’m looking at you.”
“It’s exactly how you’re looking at me.”
It was. I turned toward the window so she couldn’t see, and my reflection stared back, small and gray-eyed and furious, with a pencil still in my hair.
“He asked me to write the vows,” I said. “Did you know that?”
“Yes.”
“You knew.”
“He told me in Boston. I said it was cruel. He said it was the only honest thing he’d ever do.” A tremor ran through her voice. “Nora, I told him you’d say no.”
“I did say no.”
“Then why do you still have his notes in your coat?”
I looked down. The folded paper stuck out of my pocket, a pale tongue of lined edge. I had not even felt myself take it.
I pushed it back in. Slowly. The way you hide a bruise.
“Do you love him?” I asked.
I have written that question into three hundred letters. Husbands to wives, mothers to estranged daughters, a retired schoolteacher to the man she had never married. It is the simplest question in the world. In my own mouth it tasted like a coin.
Wren turned in her seat and looked at me squarely, with her chin up, and I saw her try. I saw her gather all of herself, the way she used to gather before jumping off the end of the town pier in June.
“I love him,” she said. “I love him, Nora. I swear it.”
And under her breath, so softly she could not have known she was doing it, my sister began to hum.