Chapter 2
WHAT THE CLOCK KEPT
The cassette was in my cardigan sleeve before I knew I had decided anything.
That is how my hands work. They move first and let the rest of me catch up, which is probably why I am good at splicing tape and bad at everything else. I slid it into the cuff, closed my fingers over the cold plastic, and stayed on my knees with my other palm flat against the clock’s lower door.
“Maren?”
“It’s stuck,” I said. “The latch. I thought I’d finally fix it.”
“At six in the evening. With dinner on.”
“I heard the rattle.” That part was true, and I let the truth carry the rest. “Doesn’t it sound off to you? Every fourth beat. Like a button in a drawer.”
Daniel stood in the kitchen doorway with a dish towel over his shoulder. He did not look at the clock. He looked at me, at my knees on the floorboards, at the hand pressed to the walnut. Then he glanced at the clock the way you glance at a stranger’s dog, to see whether it bites.
“It’s done that for two years,” he said.
“I know.”
“You told me you liked it. You said it sounded like your grandmother’s house.”
“I do. I did.” I pushed the little door shut. It clicked as though it had never been opened. “Is that thyme?”
He held out his hand. I took it with the other one, the empty one, and he pulled me upright with that easy strength of his. His palm was warm and dry. Mine was not.
“Come eat,” he said.
So I ate. Chicken thighs, crisp skin, a pan sauce he had made from nothing. I cut it into pieces and moved the pieces around the plate and said it was wonderful. Daniel talked about a client in Harlow who wanted a glass staircase and no handrail. I laughed in the right places. Under the table my left arm lay across my lap with the cassette pressed against my wrist bone like a second pulse.
I am a good listener. It is the one thing everyone agrees on. Priya says it is a superpower and my mother says it is a way of hiding. Both are right. That night I listened to my husband the way I would listen to a tape I did not trust, and I heard nothing wrong. Not a hitch. Not a crack. His voice was the voice that had read to me through the worst winter of my life.
That was what frightened me. A lie should leave a seam.
“You’re quiet,” he said, stacking plates.
“Tired.”
“Ruth’s coming Sunday. She wants to bring the lemon cake.” He ran water over the pan. “I told her you might not be up for it.”
“I’m fine for the cake.”
“Okay.” He smiled at the window over the sink, where I could see him reflected. “Okay.”
The night Tess died, I was in a hotel in Portland, Oregon, at a conference on tape preservation. I had silenced my phone at nine because the keynote ran long and I wanted to sleep. I woke at six to nine missed calls from Daniel, and one text, which I had read so many times since that I could see its shape with my eyes closed. Call me. Please. It’s Tess.
I had checked my call log a hundred times in the months after. Nothing from Tess. No missed call, no voicemail, nothing at 11:52 p.m. or any minute near it. I had told myself that was a mercy. If she had called, I would have had to live with silence on my end.
But she had called. Someone had caught the message, held it for fourteen months, and let it go.
After dinner I told Daniel I would work in the spare room for an hour.
“On a Wednesday?”
“The wedding tape. I told Priya I’d have it done.”
He dried his hands. “Want tea?”
“I’m okay.”
“I’ll bring tea.”
The spare room is my home studio, a desk, two monitors, a shelf of decks older than I am, a window that looks out at the neighbor’s fence. I closed the door and sat very still until I heard him on the stairs. Then I pulled a shoebox from the bottom shelf and dug through rubber bands and dead batteries until my fingers found the Olympus Pearlcorder. A micro cassette player the size of a deck of cards. It had been my first piece of gear, a gift from my father, who gave nothing else.
I put in fresh batteries. They were not fresh. They were four years old. The little wheel turned slowly and then caught.
Daniel knocked and came in with the tea. I had my headphones on and a reel of wedding tape spooling on the main deck, the splice from the afternoon, the Pearlcorder hidden under a folded cardigan on my lap. He set the mug at my elbow. He stood behind my chair for what felt like a long time.
“You’ll go blind in this light,” he said, and kissed the top of my head, and left the door open a hand’s width.
I counted. Sixty seconds. Ninety. A hundred and twenty. Somewhere downstairs the television went on, low, a late quiz show. I rose, shut the door as softly as I could, and sat on the floor in the corner with my back to the wall and the headphones plugged into the tiny machine.
I pressed play.
Hiss. Warm and wide, the hiss of a cheap cassette recorded in a quiet room. And in it, close to the microphone, my sister.
“Okay. Is this on? It’s on, the little red light is going.” A breath. A short laugh with no joy in it. “Hi, Mare.”
I put my hand over my mouth.
“If you’re hearing this, I chickened out of telling you to your face, which, yes. Classic me. Let’s not.” Something rustled, fabric against the mic. “I’m in your hallway. I know. I know. Daniel’s at the Harlow dinner till eleven, and you’re in Portland, and I have a key because you gave me one, which I’m going to feel terrible about in a minute. Okay?”
The clock ticked behind her. Tick. Pause. Tick. Pause. And the brass rattle, on every fourth.
“Remember when I did the photo job at Marlow Court? The insurance thing, the terrace that came down? That summer, three years ago. A boy died. Eli Voss. He was twenty-two, he was on the third floor, he stepped out for a cigarette.” Her voice dropped. “I took six hundred pictures that week. Nobody asked me to look at them closely, I was just supposed to document. But last month Eli’s mother found me. She sent me a folder. And I went back through my own files, and I looked.”
The tape hissed.
“The anchor bolts, Mare. The drawings Daniel’s firm signed off on say one thing. The steel in my pictures says another. Cheaper. Fewer. Somebody changed the schedule, and the site inspection report that went to the review board has Daniel’s name on it.”
I stopped the tape. I could not tell if the sound in the room was my breath or the clock downstairs. I pressed play again.
“I’m not saying he did it on purpose. He’s not a monster, I don’t think he’s a monster. I think he signed what somebody put in front of him and then watched it go wrong, and then couldn’t say so, because he’s Daniel, and Daniel can’t stand a room that’s broken.” She breathed in. “He knows I know. I asked him last week and he looked at me and said, ‘You’re upset, let’s not do this tonight,’ and made me a sandwich. A sandwich! I wanted to scream.”
Despite everything, a wet laugh got out of me.
“I’ve got copies. I’ve put them somewhere safe. That’s tape two. It’s where you found me the first time, remember? Where you sat and cried and said you’d never let me out of your sight again. You’ll know. Okay? You’ll know.”
I did know.
The words went through me like a nail. The quarry at Harlan Ridge. The summer I was fourteen and she was ten. The cold green water that closed over her head while I was watching a dragonfly. The ledge where I had sat afterward with her wrapped in my hoodie, both of us shaking, and promised God something I had failed to keep.
“I’m scared,” Tess said, very quietly. “I don’t want to be, but I am. If anything weird happens, if I seem to fall off the face of the earth, don’t let anyone tell you I was reckless. I was careful. For once I was really careful.”
Another sound, then, small and wet, the click of a throat.
“I love you, Mare. I’m sorry I never told you things. I thought I was protecting you. I think I was just protecting me.”
The tape ran on, empty, for several seconds. I thought it was over. I almost took the headphones off.
Then, far away down a corridor in the tiny recording, a door opened. Not the front door. A heavier sound, a deadbolt turning, the swell of night air.
“Oh no,” Tess whispered. “He’s early.”
Footsteps on hardwood. Keys in a bowl. The bright, easy voice of a man coming home to a quiet house, calling out as he came.
“Tess? Is that your car in the drive?”
The cassette clicked and stopped.
Daniel had told the police he was home all evening. That he never saw her. That she never came.
I sat in the corner of the room with my husband’s voice still in my ears, and from downstairs, through the floor, the television laughed.