Chapter 1: THE VOICE ON THE LINE0% read • ~7 min

Chapter 1

THE VOICE ON THE LINE

7 min read•1,455 words

The voicemail was fourteen seconds long, and it was in my dead sister’s voice.

I was bent over a reel of wedding tape from 1974, easing a splice back into place with tweezers, when my phone buzzed against the steel bench. I almost ignored it. Then the screen lit up and I saw the name, and the tweezers went somewhere across the room.

TESS MOBILE. One new voicemail.

Her number had been disconnected for over a year. Daniel had handled it the week after the funeral, sitting at our kitchen table with a pen and a list, canceling a dead woman’s phone plan, her gym membership, her streaming accounts. I had kept the contact anyway. Some mornings I scrolled to her name just to look at it.

Under the name, in small gray letters: Received today. Recorded the night of her death, 11:52 p.m.

“Maren?” Priya said from the next desk. “You’ve gone the color of the tape.”

“Give me a minute.”

I carried the phone into the stairwell, because the studio walls are thin and I did not want anyone else to hear what I was about to hear. I sat on the third step. The concrete was cold through my jeans. I put the phone to my ear.

Wind first. A rough, ragged rush of it, the sound of a microphone being punished. Then breathing, quick and shallow. Then my sister.

“Mare. It’s me.” A swallow. “Okay, listen. Don’t let Daniel find the second tape. Please. Don’t let him. I’ll explain, I swear, I just need you to... okay? Okay.”

A click. Silence.

I played it again. Then again. By the fourth time I was no longer listening to her words. I was listening the way I listen for a living, the way you do when a recording is lying to you and you have to find where.

Tess’s voice sat on top. Underneath was the room.

Not a lake. Not a cove. There was no water in that recording, no gulls, no wind except what her mouth made against the microphone. And beneath the wind, so faint that no one who had not spent twelve years with headphones clamped to her skull would ever have caught it, was a slow, dry, wooden tick.

Tick. Pause. Tick. Pause. And a shallow brass rattle on every fourth beat, like a loose button in a drawer.

I knew that rattle. I had been trying to fix it for two years.

My mouth went dry. I took my headphones out of my bag, plugged them in, and played the voicemail a fifth time, louder, with my eyes shut.

The hallway clock. The one my grandmother left me. The one that stood in our house, in our hallway, six feet from our front door.

Tess had said she was at the cove that night. That was what Daniel told the police. Tess had texted him around ten, upset about a fight with her landlord, and said she needed air. She drove to Pellam Cove. They found her car at the overlook. They found her three days later.

She never came to our house, Daniel had said. Never called. We would have helped.

Fourteen months of that sentence. I had rested my whole weight on it.

I counted the seconds without meaning to, a bad habit since childhood. One. Two. Three. I got to forty before I could stand.

Priya was waiting by the door when I came back in. She took one look at my face and put down her coffee. “Okay, who died?”

“Nobody.” My voice sounded borrowed. “I need to go home.”

“It’s two in the afternoon.”

“I know what time it is.”

“Maren.” She said my name carefully, like carrying something hot. “You want me to come?”

“No.” Too quick. I forced a breath. “No. It’s the tape from Monday. I’ll finish it tonight.”

She did not believe me. But she let me go, and that is the kind of friend she is.

Daniel was cooking when I got home.

I smelled it from the porch: garlic, browned butter, something with thyme. The house felt the way it always did when he was home early, warm and lit and orderly. Through the window I saw him at the stove with his sleeves pushed up, tasting from a wooden spoon.

He looked up when the door opened and smiled. That smile had gotten me through the worst year of my life.

“You’re early,” he said.

“Slow day.”

“Come here.” He held out his arm without putting down the spoon, and I crossed the kitchen and let him fold me against his side. He smelled of onions and clean laundry. His heartbeat was steady against my ear. I found myself listening to that too, and hated myself for it.

“You’re cold,” he said. “Hands like ice.”

“I walked from the station.”

“Sit. Eat something. You skip lunch when you’re stressed.”

“I’m not stressed.”

He glanced at me, just a half second too long, and went back to the pan. “Okay.”

Behind me, in the hall, the clock ticked.

I had walked past it ten thousand times and never heard it. Now it came through the doorway like a second pulse, slow and dry and impossible to ignore. Tick. Pause. Tick. Pause. And on every fourth beat, the little brass rattle.

“Dan,” I said. “Did anyone ever come by the house? That night? Before the police, I mean.”

The spoon stopped.

It was a small thing. If you did not know his hands, you would not have noticed. But I know his hands. I know that when he is truly relaxed they move without finishing, drifting from the knife to the salt to the towel. This time they stopped, completely, for exactly as long as it takes to decide something.

“Which night?” he asked.

“You know which.”

“Mare.” He set the spoon on its rest. He turned the burner down, the way he always does before a serious conversation, so no one can accuse the dinner of burning. “We’ve been over this. Tess never came here. I wish she had.”

“I know.”

“Then why are you asking?”

“Because I can’t stop wondering what she was thinking.”

It was close enough to true that it came out smoothly. He studied me a moment, his thumb pressing the edge of his shirt pocket where cigarettes used to live. Then his face softened, and he crossed the kitchen and put his hands on my shoulders.

“You’ve been doing so well,” he said quietly. “Please don’t start this again. You know where it takes you.”

I did. It took me to the bathroom floor, to the bottle of sleeping pills in the cabinet, to six weeks of my mother’s silence and Ruth’s casseroles. It took me to the version of me that Daniel had carried through the dark.

“I know,” I said. “I’m sorry.”

“Don’t be sorry.” He kissed my forehead. “Go wash up. Dinner in ten.”

I went. I washed my hands in the downstairs bathroom with the water running loud enough to cover my breathing, and then I turned it off and stood very still and listened to the house.

The refrigerator hummed. A pan hissed. Daniel was humming under his breath, off key, a song I did not know.

And the clock ticked.

Second tape, Tess had said.

There was a first tape. There had to be. And Tess had known, that night, that her husband’s wife was the only person on earth who would know what to do with it.

I walked out into the hallway. Daniel’s back was to me, framed in the kitchen doorway, bent over the cutting board. The knife made a rapid, rhythmic sound against wood.

The clock stood against the wall in its old walnut case, taller than me, its brass face dull with fifty years of hands. I had never opened the lower door. It stuck. I had always meant to fix it.

I knelt. I pressed my fingers to the seam and it gave with a soft pop, as if someone had loosened it recently.

Inside, behind the dead pendulum weight and a rolled square of felt, a small object had been wedged into the corner with a strip of masking tape.

A micro cassette. I turned it over with a shaking thumb. On the label, in my sister’s looping, impatient handwriting, were two words and a number.

FOR MARE. 1 of 2.

The knife in the kitchen stopped.

I did not turn around. I did not breathe. I only heard, behind me, the slow creak of a floorboard under my husband’s weight, and then his voice, very gentle, very close.

“Maren,” Daniel said. “What are you doing down there?”