Chapter 1
THE FOURTH FACE
There were four people in the photograph, and I could only name three.
It hung at the top of the stairs in the house we had inherited from a woman I never met, in a frame the color of old tea, and I saw it first because I was carrying a lamp and had nothing else to look at. Daniel on the left, in the green jacket he wore for years. Junie in the middle, ten or so, squinting into the sun. Me on the right, thinner than I am now, laughing at something outside the frame.
And a boy.
He stood between Junie and me with a red kite string wound around one fist and his other hand tucked inside mine. Seven, maybe. Gap-toothed, cowlick, a scab on his chin. He was looking up at me instead of the camera, with the shameless adoration only small children and dogs can manage.
I knew the photograph was ours. The dune grass, Gannet Point, the August before last. I knew the jacket and the laugh. I knew the weight of that small hand, because my own fingers were curled around it, bent in exactly the way you hold a hand you have held ten thousand times.
I did not know the boy.
“Daniel,” I called. My voice went up the stairwell and came back smaller.
He appeared at the foot of the steps with a box labeled KITCHEN, KNIVES, DON’T DROP in his arms. “Found the main breaker. It’s behind a cabinet in the pantry. Who builds a breaker behind a...” He saw my face. “What?”
“Come and look at this.”
He set the box down and climbed. Daniel climbs stairs like a man apologizing to them. He stopped one step below me, and looked where I pointed, and for a moment nothing in his face moved at all.
“That’s Gannet Point.”
“Yes.”
“That’s your hair before you cut it.”
“Who’s the boy?”
It took him a long time to answer. I counted three of his breaths, which is an old habit from my hospice years, something that happens in me without my say-so.
“Somebody’s kid,” he said. “A cousin. One of the Hallorans’ boys, maybe, from the beach house.” He cleared his throat. “We took a lot of photos that summer.”
“He’s holding my hand.”
“Kids do that.”
“Daniel.”
“Clara.” His voice was gentle, careful, the voice he had used for two years, a man crossing a frozen pond. “We are not doing this tonight. Okay? We only just got here. Let’s get the beds up and have one decent night’s sleep, and tomorrow we’ll look at the house.”
He kissed my temple. He went down the stairs. He did not look back at the photograph, not once, and I understood in the pit of my stomach that he was working very hard not to.
I stood there a moment longer with my lamp. And then, because I could not bear to be the only one looking, I turned the frame to face the wall.
The house was called Hallowell House, which sounded like a nursery rhyme, and it sat at the far edge of a village called Dunmere with the sea at its back and no neighbors near enough to hear you shout. Three stories of gray clapboard. Thirty-one rooms by the lawyer’s count. Bay windows whose glass had gone wavy with age, so that the whole front of the house seemed to be gently underwater.
It had belonged to my great-aunt Agnes Larrow, my grandmother’s sister, who had lived in it for eighty-four years and had left it, in a will drawn up in an unsteady hand eight months before she died, to me. By name. I had met her once, when I was four. Apparently she had thought of me for the next thirty-four years.
We had come because there was nowhere else. That was how I would have put it, the practical version. The mortgage on the old house had gone. The school in Portland had stopped being a place Junie could breathe. The lawyer’s letter had arrived on the first morning in two years that I had not wanted to stay in bed until the world ended. Nobody said the other version aloud. In our family we have become good at the other version, the way some families are good at piano.
Walter Quill arrived at dusk.
He was seventy or thereabouts, a barn door of a man in a canvas coat, with a ring of iron keys at his belt as big as a dinner plate. He had looked after the house for forty years, he told us, and Agnes had left him a pension and instructions. He gave us the keys one at a time, naming them like children. Kitchen. Pantry. Cellar, which he said we would not need. The east room, which he said we should keep shut.
“Why?” Daniel asked.
“Damp.” Quill did not blink. “Gets in the plaster.”
He hung his cap on the newel post and walked into the hall to look at the walls. I watched him find the photograph I had turned around. He stood a while looking at the blank back of the frame. Then he took the cap off the post, which he had only just hung up, and held it against his chest, the way men do at funerals.
“Mrs. Brandt,” he said. “Might I offer a piece of advice?”
“Please.”
“Whatever you leave in a room, you leave.” His eyes stayed on the wall. “The house isn’t unkind. But it keeps things. Mind what you put down.”
I smiled, because I did not know what else to do. “I’ll make a note of it.”
“Do.” He put on his cap, and went out into the dark, and I heard his truck cough away down the lane. I have thought a good deal since about how gently he said it. And about how he never once asked who was in the picture.
The kitchen was the warmest room in the house.
I noticed it the moment I walked in, before I had even found the light. A long scrubbed table, copper pots on iron hooks, a black range as big as a small car. The ceiling was low and the windows were small, and the whole room glowed, a thick gold glow like honey held up to a candle, though the bulb overhead was an ordinary sixty watts.
“Huh,” said Daniel, from the pantry door.
He held a loaf of bread. It was round and brown and split along the top, and as he turned it over in his hands I saw the steam rising.
“There was a whole shelf of these,” he said. “In the pantry. We’ve been here three hours. Nobody’s baked anything.”
“Maybe Quill left it.”
“Maybe.” He broke it open and the smell rolled up, yeast and warm crust, the smell of every kitchen I had ever loved. He tore off a piece and put it in my mouth, the way he used to when we were young and broke, and I laughed with my mouth full, and it was only afterward that I realized I had not laughed in a very long time.
We ate it with butter from the pantry and tea from a pot I did not remember filling. Junie sat cross-legged on a chair with crumbs on her chin and told us about the window seat she had found on the third floor, how the glass was green when you looked through it and the sea looked like a different sea. Daniel put on a record from a box of Agnes’s old vinyl. The needle caught on something low and slow and sweet. And my husband stood, wiped his hands on his jeans, and held one out to me.
“Dance with me, Clara.”
“We’re in a kitchen.”
“It’s a big kitchen.”
I took it. We turned slowly in the golden light on the old flagstones, my cheek against the wool of his cardigan, his beard catching in my hair, and I felt something inside my chest loosen.
I want to describe it exactly, because I have gone back over it a thousand times. For two years I had carried an ache under my breastbone, low and dull, like a swallowed stone. It had never once gone away. I had learned to breathe around it and to talk around it and to sleep with it wedged beside me like a second body. And in that kitchen, in my husband’s arms, it came loose. Simply that. A knot sliding free, a weight lifting off a lung. My breath went all the way to the bottom of me and stayed there.
I thought: this is what it feels like to be well.
I remember that I was grateful.
It was Junie who set the table.
I had not asked her to. She had just gone to the dresser while Daniel and I danced, taken down plates and bowls from the rack, and arranged them with the small fussy precision she brought to every task, forks on the left, spoons on the right, napkins folded in triangles. When the music stopped and Daniel went to turn the record, I looked at the table and counted the places.
Four.
“Sweetheart,” I said, “there are only three of us.”
Junie looked at the plates. She looked at me.
I will never forget her face. It was a very still face, the face she wears when she is trying to decide whether a grown-up can be trusted with something. She was twelve and she looked about forty.
“I always do four,” she said.
“Why?”
“I don’t know.”
A pause. A pause too long for a child who did not know.
Then she picked up the fourth plate, slowly, with both hands, as if it were hot, and carried it back to the dresser and set it face down in the rack. She did not say anything else. She wiped her palms on her jeans and sat in her chair.
And the ache, the one that had loosened a moment ago, did not come back.
That frightened me more than anything else that night. I know that now. I should have been frightened then. But I was warm and well-fed and half-dancing, and I sat down at that table and let the gold light settle over me like a blanket, and I did not examine it. Why would I? Something terrible had gone out of me. I wanted to believe it was grief finally leaving.
I put Junie to bed at ten.
She had taken the room at the top of the third-floor stairs, with the green window seat and a slanted ceiling and a bed that had belonged to somebody’s grandmother. She lay under the quilt with the lamp on, because she always had the lamp on, and she watched me turn down the covers with that same still look.
“Mom?”
“Mm.”
“Do you still do the song about the boat?”
“What song?”
“The one you sing. When I can’t sleep.” She spoke very carefully. “It goes up and then it goes down, and there’s a part about the tide.”
I opened my mouth, and there was nothing in it.
Not a tune. Not a single word. It was not that I had forgotten, the way you forget a name. It was a blank place, clean and warm and perfectly smooth, as if a hand had passed over a chalkboard and left it blacker than before. I stood with my mouth open and searched for it and found a room with the furniture taken out.
“I’ll remember it tomorrow,” I said.
Junie turned her face to the wall.
“That’s what Dad said,” she whispered. And then, so softly I almost lost it under the sound of the wind in the eaves, “Please don’t forget it too.”
“Forget what, baby?”
She did not answer. I stayed until her breathing slowed. I did not count it, for the first time in years. Then I turned off the lamp and shut the door and went down the long hall to the bathroom, with my own breath loud in my ears.
It was a big bathroom with a clawfoot tub and a window that looked out on the dark sea. Daniel had already unpacked the toothbrushes. They stood in a glass on the sink, his green one and my white one and Junie’s pink, and I reached out to take mine, and my foot knocked the wastebasket.
It tipped. A tissue, a cotton ball, a scrap of tape, a smear of toothpaste.
And a toothbrush.
A very small one. Blue, with a dinosaur on the handle, its bristles bent flat and splayed, chewed at the neck the way children chew them. I had not packed it. I would have sworn to that in a court of law. I had unpacked every box in that bathroom with my own hands, and there was no child in this house who used a toothbrush like that, and still I was kneeling on the cold tile with it in my fingers.
My thumb knew the shape.
That was the horror of it. My thumb found the ridge in the handle where it had been bitten and fitted itself there perfectly, the way a tongue finds a missing tooth. My chest hurt, low and sharp, in a place I could not locate, as though I had been struck by something a very long time ago and only now remembered it was bruised. I knelt there. I could not breathe.
I did not know whose it was.
Somewhere below me, in the dark kitchen, where the golden light had been switched off hours before, something moved. A chair scraped. A cupboard door whispered closed. And a voice, very small and very close to the floor, as if from a child standing in the kitchen doorway in his socks, called up through the sleeping house.
“Mom?”
It was not Junie’s.