Chapter 10: A BOWL OF BUTTERSCOTCH CANDIES0% read • ~7 min

Chapter 10

A BOWL OF BUTTERSCOTCH CANDIES

7 min read•1,573 words

We hid the steel box in Theo’s proofing cabinet, under a rack of rising rye, and Theo stood in front of it with his arms folded like a man guarding a cathedral.

“Back door’s open,” he said. “I told you.”

“I know.”

“I mean it. Go find her. I’ll sit on these loaves till Easter.”

I did not hug him. I put my forehead briefly against his shoulder, in the warm smell of yeast, and I felt his big hand land between my shoulder blades and stay there for exactly one breath. Then I went out with Eli into a Friday that had turned to pewter. We left Dot behind us in the green room with her coat and her silence and the door pulled almost to.

“Where?” Eli said.

“Where would you go if you were twenty-eight and stupid and in love with the idea of being the one who fixes things?”

“I know where I went.”

“The pier.”

“The pier,” he agreed, and we walked fast.

Calloway Pell kept his office above the old ice house, at the top of an outside stair with an iron railing slick with salt. The window was large and round, like a ship’s porthole. A brass plate by the door said PELL HOLDINGS and underneath, in smaller letters, as if embarrassed, EST. 1961. Light burned in the window. And in the window, quite small and gold and clear, sat my sister.

She had on the good coat. She sat very straight in a leather chair with her knees together, and across a wide desk from her, one hand resting on a cream document, sat Pell. He was offering her something from a glass bowl.

Eli took the stairs three at a time. I took them two and a half. I did not knock.

“Wren.”

She turned. Her face was white under her gray hat, and her mouth was pressed shut, and in her hand, uncapped, she held a pen.

“Nora,” she said. “I said not to follow me.”

“You’ve never once in your life done what a note told you.”

“This was a good note.”

“It had a lilac on it.”

“I thought that was a nice touch.” She laughed, a thin, shivering sound. Her free hand rose to her throat. And she began, very quietly, to hum.

Pell watched the hum. He watched it with the mild, benevolent interest of a man watching a clock he’d wound. He was in a gray cardigan today instead of the camel coat, with a silk handkerchief in the pocket, and there was a glass bowl of butterscotch candies at his elbow, the kind wrapped in gold cellophane. He held one out to me.

“Miss Vale. Do come in. Mr. Hartwell, I’d hoped you’d come. Please sit. I’ve been having the most delightful conversation with your intended.”

“I’ll stand,” Eli said.

“As you like.” Pell unwrapped the candy himself and put it in his mouth. “Wren came to me this morning of her own accord, which I took as a very mature gesture. She has decided to sign the transfer.”

“Wren,” I said.

“I’m fixing it,” she whispered. “It’s my fault, Nora. It’s all my fault. If I sign, he forgives the note, and Eli’s free, and Dot’s free, and you’re free, and nobody ever has to say my name in a courtroom.”

“And the shop?”

“It’s only a building.”

“It’s Dot’s whole life.”

“Dot’s already given it to him,” Wren said. “She’s been paying him for seven years.”

That one hit me squarely under the ribs. I opened my mouth, and nothing came out.

“A tidy and sensible girl,” said Pell, warmly. “Takes after her aunt.”

“She doesn’t take after her aunt,” I said. “Her aunt would rather eat the pen.”

“Ah.” His smile widened a fraction. “And you, I suppose, are the one who takes after the father.”

“Don’t talk about my father.”

“I wouldn’t dream of it.” He slid the cream document across the desk to me with one finger. “You’ll notice that two of three owners suffice. If you’d like to add your own signature to your sister’s, the transaction closes today, and Dorothea’s objection becomes quite academic. I’d rather it was a family decision. I find it more graceful.”

I did not take the paper. I did something I do without thinking, the one habit I cannot kill. I picked it up and began to read it aloud.

“The Grantors, being the undersigned owners of the premises known as Vale and Daughters, Fisher Street, convey to the Grantee all right, title and interest in said premises, together with all fixtures, fittings, and appurtenances thereto.”

“Standard,” said Pell.

“Together with all contents of the premises, whether visible or concealed, sealed or unsealed, inclusive of any structure, chamber, or void within the walls thereof.”

The room went quiet. Out on the water, a buoy tolled.

Wren stopped humming.

“That’s not standard,” I said.

“It’s thorough.”

“Inclusive of any chamber or void.” I looked at him over the top of the paper, and I kept my voice mild, with the dry precise tone I use on clients who tell me they were wrong in the first line. “Why would a man buying a stationery shop want the voids?”

For the first time, something moved in Pell’s face. It was no more than a flicker, a tiny tightening around the pale eyes, but I had been reading faces across my counter for nine years, and I knew what I had seen. It was a man hearing a hymn he thought nobody else knew.

“Lawyers,” he said lightly. “They will write it all down.”

“Wren,” I said. “Don’t sign.”

“Nora...”

“Put the pen down.”

“I can’t.” Her voice cracked. “I can’t go on being the girl you have to carry. I did it once. I did it wrong. Let me do it right.”

“It’s not a thing you can do right,” I said. “That’s the point. It was never yours alone to carry. That’s what I’ve been trying to tell you for seven years and I never said it.”

Her hand shook. The pen’s nib hovered over the line, a bright blue bead gathering at its tip.

“He’ll send you to prison,” she whispered.

“He won’t.”

“You don’t know that.”

“I don’t,” I said, honestly. “But I know this. I’d rather lose the shop standing next to you than keep it and lose you again. I wrote a hundred letters this year about forgiveness, Wren, and I never once had the nerve to write my own.”

She looked at me. Her eyes, my eyes, filled. The pen came down, slowly, an inch at a time, and rested beside the paper.

It did not touch the line.

Pell watched all of this with great composure. He popped another candy in his mouth. Then he lifted the receiver on his desk phone, an old black one with a cord, and spoke into it very quietly, three words I could not hear. He set it back in its cradle.

“Well,” he said. “That is a pity. Truly. I had hoped it might be done kindly.”

“Mr. Pell,” said Eli. It was the first time he had spoken in some minutes, and his voice was dangerously level. “Whatever you’ve just done, undo it.”

“I have done nothing at all. I merely made a telephone call.” He rose and went to the round window and stood with his hands behind his back, looking down at the fog and the harbor. “You’ll forgive an old man his curiosity. Marian kept things, you know. She was a great keeper. I’ve wondered for twenty-four years where she put them. And I’ve been so patient.”

My blood went cold.

“I never had the key,” Pell said, still looking out. “That’s what delayed me. A man can stand outside a door for a very long time if he knows he can’t open it. But you see, Mr. Hartwell, it occurred to me this morning that you might be carrying it. And that a person who carries a key will sooner or later bring it to a lock.”

“You followed us.”

“My dear boy. I have eyes on every one of these streets. I had them on your father.”

Eli moved. I do not know how he crossed the room so fast. He had Pell by the cardigan, against the glass, and the handkerchief spilled from the pocket and fluttered to the floor, and the candy bowl rang on the desk.

“Eli!” I said.

Pell did not struggle. He looked at Eli’s hand on his chest, then up into his face, with a gentle, pitying, awful smile. “Do let go. I’d hate for Miss Delacroix to hear that you’d laid a hand on me.”

Eli went absolutely still.

“Yes,” said Pell. “I know about her too.”

Then, from far down the waterfront, from the direction of Fisher Street, came the first long, ragged note of the church bell, rung wrong, rung hard, rung by someone who did not care how it sounded.

I ran to the window. Over the rooftops, beyond the cannery stacks, a dark column of smoke was rising straight into the fog, thick and oily, with a hot orange heart.

It was coming from the shop.

“Dot,” I whispered.

“A shop full of paper,” Pell said gently, straightening his cardigan. “I have always said it was a terrible hazard. Everything burns, my dear. It’s only paper.”