Chapter 23: TWO BOYS AND ONE WATER0% read • ~9 min

Chapter 23

TWO BOYS AND ONE WATER

9 min read•1,897 words

The dark lasted perhaps four seconds, and in those four seconds nobody on the pier breathed.

Then a match scraped. Somebody had struck a light at the far end of the planks, and a small yellow flame rose and steadied, and by it I saw James Finn, the first one, the one who had not yet gone in. He was nineteen. He was standing on the landing in a fisherman’s jumper with a transistor radio hanging from his belt, peppermint in one cheek, a lit taper in his fist.

Beside me, the other James went rigid.

“That’s my taper,” he whispered. “That’s the one Alcyone gave me. I had it before I went in. I had it in my pocket.” He swallowed. “I never knew where it came from.”

“It came from you,” said Alcyone softly. “Later. You carried it back.”

“Hello?” called the first James, cheerful, peering into the mist. “Somebody there? I heard a splash.”

“There was no splash,” my father said, very quietly, to the dark. He had stepped in front of the child. The old Thomas, silver bearded, wearing his own face thirty years on, between his daughter and the water. “Not yet. Stay where you are, lad.”

The young Thomas had come halfway down the pier. He had stopped three paces from himself. For a long, strange moment the two men looked at each other across thirty years of weather, the one fair and strong and terrified, the other silver and thin and calm, and I watched the young one’s mouth work.

“You’re me,” he said.

“I am.”

“You’re old.”

“I’m tired. It’s different.” A faint smile. “Thomas. Listen. You’ve been dreaming this night for months. The water goes flat. The light comes up. A boy goes in, and you stand there holding your daughter, and you let him.”

“I didn’t let him.”

“You didn’t stop him. I know. I’ve been telling myself it was the same thing for twenty-eight years.” He held out one hand, palm up, in the lamplight. “Tonight you get to stop him.”

“How?”

“Not me. I haven’t the right. Him.” He nodded past the young man’s shoulder, to the child in the rabbit nightdress, who had wandered, quite unconcerned, to sit on the edge of the planks with her feet dangling over the black. “She isn’t going to fall, Tom. Not if somebody is holding her hand.”

The young man stared at the child. Then he crossed the planks in four strides, dropped to one knee, and gathered her up.

“Daddy,” she said, with enormous dignity, “I’m not a baby.”

“No,” said Thomas, and his voice cracked. “No, you’re not. You never were.”

She was in his arms. She was safe, dry, warm, with her face against the oilskin and her small cold feet tucked under his elbow. I saw it. I watched my own father, thirty-one, lift me up off the edge of that pier and hold on as though the sea itself were going to take me out of his hands, and something enormous and unnameable turned over in my chest.

I had no memory of it. I had no memory of what came after, either. The pen had taken the cake and the tide and the long grey years that followed, and what it had left was this: a man holding a child, and a faint, clean ache, like the memory of a toothache you have stopped having.

“That’s one,” said Alcyone. “She will not fall.”

But the water was already moving.

It began as a hush. Out in the bay, where the bell buoy had been, the sea lay down flat, perfectly flat, a mile of black glass reflecting a sky with no stars. The gold rose in it, slow, like a coin sinking in reverse. I felt the lamp in my chest answer. The blue light beside it flared.

The map wanted its name.

“Ah,” said the first James, to nobody, delighted. “There’s the glow. Mum always says don’t look at it. Mum’s wrong, it’s beautiful.”

“James!” The second James had run forward before any of us could stop him. He caught the boy by both shoulders and spun him round, and I saw the two faces side by side. The same freckles. The same chipped tooth. The same jaw, Maggie’s stubborn jaw. One rested. One twenty-eight years tired. “Listen to me. Don’t look at it. Don’t answer.”

The first James stared at him. His grin went slowly out.

“You’re me,” he said.

“Yes.”

“Are you dead?”

“No. I’m worse. I’m a lantern.” The older boy tried to laugh and it caught in his throat. “I’ve been sitting in the dark for twenty-eight years keeping a light lit so Mum’s boy could come home. It was a very long wait, and you can’t do it. You haven’t the patience. But I’m asking you not to say yes.”

“Why?”

“Because it will ask. It will say, I think it wants me, Mum, and you’ll smile and you’ll say it, because you’re kind and you always have been, and you’ll walk in with your arms out.” His voice shook. “I know. I remember. It was lovely. It was the loveliest thing I ever felt. And then it was twenty-eight years.”

“Then who goes?” said the first James, very softly.

“Nobody.”

“It needs a name.”

“It’s had one. Kessler.” Alcyone had come up on his other side. “He gave himself for his wife and for my brother’s sake. The map took him tonight. In this night. The debt is paid.”

“Then why is it still glowing?” said the first James.

Nobody answered. Because he was right.

The gold in the bay had not faded. It had grown. It rolled in toward the pier in a long smooth swell, silent, and as it came, the planks began to hum. Every lamp along the quay flickered. A small gold circle opened on the landing, then another, then a dozen, a ring of them round the end of the pier like the faces of a clock.

My watch ticked on my wrist.

I looked down. The cracked glass. The hands. The second hand sweeping round with the old, patient, dreadful sweep I had last seen in a ship’s saloon.

It read four seventeen.

“It isn’t paid,” I said.

“Nora?” said Caleb.

“Kessler wasn’t the name. He was the first name it wanted. It said so.” I turned in a circle. “It’s counting. It isn’t one in, one out. It’s the same sum it always was. One for every door that was opened in the night.” I looked at the ring of gold, at the hundred behind us, at Liesbeth on her father’s arm. “We came through. All of us. We opened a door.”

“A hundred and four doors,” said Alcyone, very quietly.

“Then it wants a hundred and four names.”

“It wants what it is owed. It has always wanted what it is owed.” The girl with my face turned to me, and the sorrow in her expression was exact. “I told you the road went home. I did not tell you it was a loan.”

The hum rose to a whine. Along the pier, the hundred had drawn together. Voss had pushed his daughter behind him. The red-bearded Norwegian had taken up a coil of rope as if it were a weapon. And Maggie’s voice, very small and very clear, came down the thread from the present, from a boat in a grey sea twenty-eight years away.

“Nor. Love. Can you hear me?”

“I hear you.”

“Ask James. Ask my boy.” She was crying. “Ask him what he wants.”

I looked at the two boys on the landing, one nineteen and one nineteen and a lifetime. They had joined hands. I do not think either knew it.

“I want her to have the kettle,” said the first James, wonderingly. “That’s all I’ve ever wanted. For her to have the kettle on, and me coming in the door.”

“Then come in the door,” said the second.

“How?”

“I’ll show you.” He lifted the lantern. “Alcyone. The road. Can it run two ways?”

The girl hesitated. “It can run one. And back.”

“Then I’ll take his place.”

“James...”

“I’ve been it already. I know how.” He smiled at the first boy, crooked, gentle, Maggie’s own. “Go and put the kettle on, lad. I’ll hold the light. And Mum, if you can hear me, this is the thing I was always going to do.”

He walked toward the ring of gold.

I heard Maggie scream. I heard Voss say a word in Dutch. I heard Caleb’s boots, and my own, pounding on the boards, and somewhere very close my father’s voice saying, no, lad, no. But I was too far. The thread in my palm snapped taut and burned, and I flung out my left hand toward him, and the pencil, warm, alive, small, was suddenly in my fingers.

“Nora,” said Alcyone urgently. “Whatever you write, it will take more than before.”

“I know.”

“You will not remember what you came for.”

“I know that too.”

I set the stub to the planks of the old Falmouth pier, in the dark, with the water rising, and I wrote.

I wrote a door that opened both ways. I wrote a kettle. I wrote, in my own off-key hand, that nobody on this pier would be asked to pay for anybody else, and that a lantern, once lit, may be set down.

The gold stopped.

It hung in the air, a hundred and four bright rings, trembling like a held note. And in the sudden, shuddering silence, James Finn, the older one, turned at the edge of the planks with his taper in his fist and an expression of pure astonishment.

He was no longer holding the lantern.

It sat on the boards behind him, burning low, and in his other hand, in the lit hand, he held a mug of tea.

It was steaming. It smelled of milk and too much sugar.

“Mum made it,” he said blankly. “It’s hot.”

Down the dark of the quay, from the window of the harbour office, a small warm light had gone on, and a woman’s voice, sharp, cracked, forty years younger, called out into the mist.

“James Finn! Whatever you’re doing on that pier, you come in this minute, your tea’s getting cold!”

The first James laughed. It rang off the water like a bell. He started toward the sound at a run, and the second went after him, the mug slopping in his fist, and I watched two boys with the same chipped tooth race each other up the pier to the light, and the dark closed after them like a door.

I felt it then. The pen’s price. It came down on me like a tide going out of a harbour, quick and enormous and without cruelty, and I stood on a wet wooden pier at the end of the world with my father’s hand on my shoulder and tried to remember why I was there.

“Dad?” I said.

“I’m here, love.”

“Who’s the man with the coin?”

He did not answer. Beside me, a broad-shouldered stranger in a leather jacket had gone perfectly still, and the coin that had been walking across his knuckles for as long as I could remember stopped dead, fell, and rang once on the planks.