Chapter 5: THE SEAT SET FOR A TALL MAN0% read • ~6 min

Chapter 5

THE SEAT SET FOR A TALL MAN

6 min read•1,293 words

I did not step away from the water.

I stood up instead, slowly, with the olive case against my ribs and my heels on the very lip of the ledge. Below me the pond lay black and flat. Above me a man in a rumpled coat stood on the path with both hands open at his sides, and I thought, with a clarity that surprised me: if I go in, he will not get to the case before it sinks.

“That’s far enough,” I said.

“Mrs. Cole.”

“You told me you never spoke to her.”

Brandt did not move. A breeze came across the quarry and lifted the corner of his coat, and for a moment he looked less like a policeman than like a man at a bus stop who has been waiting a very long time.

“Ah,” he said. “Tape.”

“Two tapes. She talked to you in a kitchen. There was a kettle.”

“Mine. It’s a bad kettle.” He said it flatly, but something in his jaw gave way. “How much did you hear?”

“Enough to know you lied.”

“I did.” He nodded slowly. “I’d like to tell you why. I’d like to do it somewhere you aren’t standing over four hundred thousand gallons of dark water holding the only evidence in the county. Could you come up?”

“How did you find me?”

“I sat outside your house this morning.” He held up one hand, palm out, as if to stop me from saying what I was thinking. “I know how that sounds. Your husband left at seven. You left at ten past, in a hurry, with a bag. I followed you. I have been following you at a distance for about two hours and I am very bad at it. You made me at the third light.”

“I didn’t.”

“You made me at the gas station. You just didn’t know you had.” He nearly smiled. “Mrs. Cole, you look at everything the way a woman looks at a wall she is thinking about knocking down. I figured you’d go somewhere that mattered.”

I had not wanted to like him. I counted, three, four, five, and I did not come away from the edge.

“Talk from there,” I said.

He sighed. He lowered himself, joint by joint, onto a flat rock beside the path, so that his head sat lower than mine. It was an old trick. I knew it was a trick, and I also knew that the man doing it was tired enough that it was not only a trick.

“Marlow Court,” he said. “Three years ago. I was the detective on the criminal referral. Terrace came down at one in the morning, one dead, four hurt. Review board looked at the paperwork and found it clean. A contractor took the blame. A fine, a citation. I had a stack of homicides on my desk and a captain who wanted the stack smaller. I closed it in three weeks.”

“Too fast.”

“Everything I close is too fast, Mrs. Cole. That’s the job. Mostly it doesn’t matter.” He looked at the water. “Then your sister walked into my station last October with a brown envelope and asked for me by name. She said, you closed Marlow Court. I said, I did. She said, I think you closed it wrong.”

“She showed you the photographs.”

“Twelve of them. I looked at the bolts and I looked at the signature block and I knew in about forty seconds that I had put a dead boy’s file in a drawer because it was easier. I told her I would reopen it quietly. I told her not to talk to anyone. And I told my captain, Lyle Marsh, because he’s my captain and that’s the chain.”

“And nine days later she was dead.”

“Eight.” He rubbed his face with both hands. “Her car turned up at the Pellam overlook. By the time they pulled her out, Marsh had already decided what kind of case it was. A depressed woman, a cold night, a cliff. He gave it to me and said, close it clean, Owen, for the family’s sake. And I did.” He laughed, a short ugly sound. “Eleven days. A new record.”

“Why would you do that?”

“Because I wanted it to be a drowning.” He said it quietly. “Because if it wasn’t, then I’d told Marsh about those photographs and a week later the woman who took them was in a lake. And I could not stand in the same room as that thought.”

I stared at him. A cold, specific sentence rose in my mind and I let it out before I could stop it.

“Then you let my husband tell you a story, and you wrote it down.”

“I wrote it down.” He met my eyes. “And I wrote something else down, and I’ve kept it in a drawer for fourteen months, and I would like you to hear it, because I think it’s the only honest thing I did.”

I waited.

“The car,” Brandt said. “Her Corolla. When the tow driver opened it at the overlook the driver’s seat was racked all the way back. Mirror angled high. Seat belt not buckled. Tess Calloway was five foot two.”

The wind shifted. Somewhere behind me the heron called, a dry rusty note, like a hinge.

“Someone tall drove that car,” I said.

“Someone tall drove that car to that overlook. I put it in my notes. Marsh said she’d had it detailed that week, maybe the car wash guy. I let him say it.” Brandt held my gaze. “I’m six foot three, Mrs. Cole. So is half the force. And your husband is six foot one.”

“Why are you telling me this?”

“Because you came to my office yesterday and you noticed the call time. 6:40. Nobody notices that. I read that report fifty times and I never noticed. And I thought, the grieving sister who counts the seconds, she’s going to take this apart whether I help her or not.” He stood, carefully, with a hand on his knee. “So I’d rather be standing next to you than behind you.”

I did not know what to believe. That is not a figure of speech. I stood on the ledge listening to him with every instinct I owned, and I could hear nothing wrong, and I had learned in the last two days exactly what that was worth.

“I’m keeping the case,” I said.

“You’re going to make copies.”

“Yes.”

“Then make them somewhere I can’t find. And put one in a place nobody connects to you.” His voice sharpened, just slightly. “Your husband’s mother. Have you seen her since the funeral?”

“She’s coming Sunday.”

“Don’t be alone with her.”

“She’s sixty seven. She brings lemon cake.”

“She sat on your sister’s sofa a week before she died and told her family looks after family.” Brandt stepped back from the path and made room for me, an old courtesy. “I’ve met a lot of killers, Mrs. Cole. Not one of them frightened me the way a nice woman who thinks she’s helping does.”

My phone buzzed against my hip.

I took it out with one hand. Priya, four texts, all capitals, the last just a skull. And above them, from a name I had read ten thousand times, one message, sent three minutes ago.

DANIEL: Mum’s here early. She brought the cake. She says she has something for you. Where are you, love? Come home.

I looked up from the screen. Brandt was watching my face.

“That’s him,” he said.

“His mother’s in my house.”

“Then I’d go home,” Brandt said, “and I’d smile, and I’d keep your hands in your pockets. And I’d turn on whatever you listen with.”

The Last Voicemail — Chapter 5: THE SEAT SET FOR A TALL MAN | BlueNov