Chapter 6
THE SILVER DOLLAR
My father had gotten small.
That was the first thing. In my head he was six feet tall in a plaid shirt with his sleeves rolled to the elbow, a man who filled doorways. The man in the bed at St. Luke’s was a drawing of that man done by someone who’d only heard him described. A hospital gown hung off his shoulders. The right corner of his mouth sagged. A wedding ring, thin as a thread, was loose on his left hand.
I stood in the doorway for a long time. It had taken me nineteen hours to get here. A Portland departure, a bad cup of coffee in Minneapolis, a night on an airport bench where I had not slept. I had read Dunne’s paper eleven times on the plane. The circle over the i. My twelve-year-old signature, perfect and cheerful, like a child writing her name on a get-well card.
“Marian,” he said.
It came out thick, the consonants softened, as if his tongue had been wrapped in cotton. But I knew my name in that voice. It had called me in from the porch for dinner.
“Dad.”
“You came.”
“You called.”
“Lorraine called.” The good half of his mouth moved. “I’m not that brave.”
A woman stood up from the chair in the corner. Sixty or so, a long grey braid down her back, reading glasses pushed into her hair, the gaunt strong look of someone who had been up two nights in a row. She didn’t offer her hand. She picked up her purse and a paperback.
“I’ll be in the cafeteria,” she said, and she squeezed my arm once as she passed, a dry hard squeeze, a woman steadying a ladder. “He’s allowed to be tired. Don’t let him say he isn’t.”
The door sighed shut. Beeps, a drip, a television on mute in the corridor.
I sat. The chair was warm from Lorraine.
“How’s the boiler?” he said.
“Knocking.”
“Pressure valve.”
“I know, Dad.”
“Tell Theo to bleed the radiators.”
“Theo’s going to lose the inn,” I said. “Theo owes a man named Corrigan eighty-two thousand dollars. I owe nothing and I’m about to lose it all anyway. Mom is dead. And I have a copy of a note in my bag with my name on it.”
His good eye closed. It stayed closed for several seconds. When it opened again I thought he was going to cry, and I braced for it, because I had never in my life seen my father cry and I wasn’t sure I could stand it.
“Show me.”
I took out the paper and held it near the bed. He read slowly, lips moving. The monitor ticked. A nurse’s shoes squeaked past in the hall.
“That’s Frank’s boy’s printing,” he said. “Frank would never have typed it.”
“Is it real?”
“Oh, it’s real.” He lowered the page. “I’m sorry. God, I’m sorry. I owe you the whole thing, and I have been practicing since the day you were born to say it right, and I can’t do it, so I’m going to say it badly.”
“Then say it.”
He looked at the ceiling. “I borrowed sixty-one thousand dollars from a man I met at the Gull to pay off other men I met at the Gull. I thought I’d win it back by spring. I signed the back lot as security. Ruthie had no idea. She found out the day of your birthday, when you found the letter.”
“I know. I read it.”
“You read it?”
“Mom wrote it all down.”
“Of course she did.” Something moved in his throat. “She wrote everything. It’s the only way she could bear anything.”
“What I need to know,” I said, and I could hear my own control sliding, “is why my name is on that paper. I didn’t witness anything. I was twelve.”
“Marian.”
“Tell me.”
He turned his face, the good half toward me. “That afternoon, your birthday, I took you to lunch. Ruthie was in Rockport at the dentist. I said I’d treat you to the Gull, which she’d never allow, and we sat at the back table, and you ordered a grilled cheese and a Shirley Temple, and you wore the green sweater.”
The green sweater. A kick under the ribs. I had not thought of the green sweater in twenty-four years.
“Frank Corrigan came and sat at our table. He was kind. Everybody forgets that. He bought you a sundae. Then he took out a card, a birthday card, a little brown one, and he said, ‘Marian, will you sign this for your dad’s friend? It’s a special card. It says you’re a grown-up.’”
I could smell it. Grease and spilled beer and cold ketchup, and the sundae, the cherry on top. A man’s big warm hand pressing a pen into mine.
“I said, ‘Sign it, honey,’” my father said. “I put the pen in your hand. You signed it. Frank gave you a silver dollar for your trouble, and you grinned at me like I’d given it to you, and I let you.”
I did not realize my hand had gone into my pocket until I felt the edge.
I have carried a silver dollar for twenty-four years. I didn’t know why. It lived in my coat pocket in the winter and my jeans in the summer, and on the bad nights I turned it over in my fingers, edge to edge, face to face, the way other people say rosaries. I had told Theo once it was from a guest. I had told myself I’d forgotten.
I took it out now and set it on the blanket between us.
His good eye filled. “You kept it.”
“I never knew why.”
“I did,” he said. “God help me, I did. Every time Lorraine said, ‘Why does that woman call you on your birthday?’ I knew. Because she was the one I used.”
The room had a thin high hum, the sound of the machines. I heard my own pulse in my ears.
“You made me a witness,” I said. “To your fraud.”
“I made you the reason I could believe it was small. A child’s signature, a birthday card. If it was only a card, it wasn’t what it was.” He shook his head. “Your mother figured it out when she found Frank’s copy in my coat. That was what finished it. Not Claire. She’d forgiven Claire years before, because Claire was her sister and she loved her and she thought the child was, “ He stopped. “Not Claire. She said to me, ‘You can lie to me. You can steal from me. You put a pen in Marian’s hand.’”
“And she told you to go.”
“And I went.” The words were rough. “And afterward I let you think it was my choice. I let you believe I walked out, because the man who walks out is a coward, and the man who’s thrown out is a thief. I preferred to be a coward. Your mother preferred to let you be angry at someone who deserved it.”
“She let me hate you.”
“She let you hate me instead of her.”
“That’s not a gift.”
“No.”
“She didn’t get to decide that for me.”
“No,” he said again. “She didn’t. I didn’t. I know that now. It took me twenty-four years and a stroke in my kitchen.”
I stood up. I walked to the window, which looked out on a parking structure and a grey slice of Lake Superior, huge and flat as a sheet of tin. I counted the cars on the third level. Eleven. I counted them again.
Behind me, my father said, “She wrote me every Christmas Eve.”
I turned.
“One line,” he said. “Not a letter. A line on a postcard. The children are fine. Twenty-four years of them. I have them in a shoebox.” He tried to laugh. “I thought she was punishing me. I understand now she was keeping me alive.”
“You never wrote back.”
“I wrote back every time. She never answered. I didn’t know whether she read them.” A shake of the head. “Yesterday Lorraine opened the last one. It came early. This one wasn’t a postcard.”
He pointed to the bedside table with a shaking left hand. A plain envelope, creased and opened. Inside, a single sheet. The tight slant, the hooked g.
Walter. I am done carrying it. Tell Marian what you did the year she turned twelve, or the ledger will. And Walter. Tell her I forgave you before she was thirty.
Below that, smaller and in a different pen, as if added in a second sitting:
I never forgave myself.
I put the page back into the envelope and set the envelope on the blanket beside the silver dollar. I could not look at either one. My throat was so tight I couldn’t have said my own name.
The phone in my bag buzzed. I almost didn’t answer. Then I saw it was June.
“Marian.” Her voice was high and thin, a voice I hadn’t heard since she was eleven. “Marian, where are you?”
“Duluth. What’s happened?”
“It’s Theo.” A sound like a breath torn in half. “He’s gone. His bed’s made again. His phone’s on the kitchen table, face up, and Dunne’s car was in the drive at four this morning, I heard the engine, I thought I was dreaming.”
“June.”
“There’s a note.” Paper rustled. “It says, ‘Don’t come after me. Let me fix one thing.’ That’s all. That’s the whole thing.”
I looked at my father in the bed, small and wrecked, with the silver dollar glinting on the blanket beside his hand. Then I looked at the grey lake, and I understood that I had done exactly what I’d always done. I had taken everything into my own two hands and left no one to hold the rest.