Chapter 2: EVERYTHING BUT THEO0% read • ~15 min

Chapter 2

EVERYTHING BUT THEO

15 min read•3,361 words

"He was your son," Iris said.

She had not meant to say it like that. She had meant to say it gently, over tea, in the kitchen, with Officer Lyle's hat on the table to hold the room together. But they had come down the hill in a silence so thick she could feel it on her skin, and by the time the gate clanged shut behind them the words were already out.

The man stopped on the gravel path.

He did not fall. He did not cry out. He stood quite still with one hand on the iron railing and the morning light on the side of his face, and she watched the sentence go into him, and she watched his face try to take it.

"Mine," he said.

"His name was Theodore. He lived two days." Her voice sounded like someone reading from a card. "You held him for most of the second one. You wouldn't let the nurse take him until I told you to."

"I don't..."

"You carried the box yourself."

His mouth opened. It closed. And then, with the terrible slowness of a man lowering himself into cold water, he sat down on the path in the wet gravel, with the bad leg stuck out in front of him, and put both hands over his eyes.

He made no noise. His shoulders only shook. She stood above him in the thin gold light and thought: I have never seen a man cry like that on purpose. It was the only thing she was sure of. The grief was real. Whatever else was wrong with him, whatever else was painted over or added or lost, the grief had no seam in it at all.

That should have comforted her. It did the opposite.

She tested him all that morning, without seeming to.

She was good at it. She had spent twelve years learning how to look at a thing for a long time without letting it know it was being looked at. She made him toast and watched which hand he buttered it with. She left a book open on the counter and watched how he read, finger under the line or not. She asked him to fetch the scissors from the second drawer, and he found it on the first try, though the drawers had been rearranged in his absence.

Left hand. Left hand. Left hand.

"Julian used to hum," she said. She had her back to him, running water over cups. "When he thought. Do you remember?"

A pause. "Bach."

"Which?"

"The Goldberg Variations. The slow one at the start."

"Can you?"

He hummed it. He hummed it quietly, with his eyes closed and his head tipped back against the chair, a long, grave, flowing line that rose and fell like breath. It was lovely. It was in tune. And as it went on, the cold thread at the back of her mind tightened another notch.

Julian had never once hummed it in tune.

He had a terrible ear. He would go wandering through the first eight bars with such confidence that she had never had the heart to tell him, and when he reached the part he could not remember he would simply stop, and frown, and go back to the start. In nine years she had never heard him reach the end.

The man at her table hummed it all the way through. Every note was right. It was beautiful, and it was a copy, and she knew the difference the way she knew a fresh stroke of paint on a hundred-year-old cracked varnish. The surface was perfect. It was too clean.

"Thank you," she said, and turned off the tap.

Eleanor Vandermeer arrived at ten, with her cane.

She did not ring. She had a key. She came up the drive in a long gray car with a driver, and stood at the kitchen door in her good wool coat, her pearl studs, and her silver bob combed flat as a helmet. She was sixty-eight. She had never in her life been seen to hurry.

She looked at the man at the table.

Iris had braced for tears, or a scream, or one of her cold, sudden, appalling collapses. Eleanor had fainted at Theo's funeral, with perfect timing, and been caught by the undertaker. But the old woman only stood very straight with both hands on the head of her cane, and a muscle moved in her cheek.

"Julian," she said.

"Mother."

"Stand up."

He did. It took him a moment, because of the knee. She crossed the kitchen in four steps, and put both hands on either side of his face, and held it, and for a very long time did nothing at all.

Iris watched her eyes.

They moved over his face the way a restorer's do, slowly, from the forehead down, along the line of the brow and the cheek and the thin white scar on the chin. They did not go to his eyes. They went everywhere else. They lingered on the shape of his ears, on the set of his jaw, on a small crease at the corner of his mouth. And something went through them that Iris could not name. Something very old and very tired, like a woman looking at a photograph from a trunk.

"You've lost weight," Eleanor said.

"I know. I'm sorry."

"Don't be sorry." Her voice was thin. "Don't ever be sorry."

She pulled him into her arms. It was the first time Iris had seen her embrace anyone. She did it stiffly, as though she had read about it, with her cane hooked over his shoulder, and she held on with a strength that made the pearls shake in her ears. She put her mouth near his ear and said something, low, quick, a few words, and he flinched.

Iris did not catch it.

"What did she say?" she asked later, in the hall.

They were alone. Eleanor was pulling on her gloves with great care, one finger at a time. The man was upstairs, lying down at Iris's insistence, and Posy had been collected by a neighbor for a play date she did not want to go to.

"Say?"

"When you hugged him."

"I said what a mother says." The old woman did not look up. "Welcome home."

"It didn't sound like that."

"Then you're hearing things." The second glove went on. "Iris. I would like you to listen to me, because I will say this only once, and I am too old to say it twice."

"I'm listening."

"Do not let anyone take that man out of this house. Not the police. Not the lawyers. Not Graham Pryce." She raised her eyes, and they were a very pale, cold blue. "Especially not Graham Pryce."

"Why?"

"Because he is my son," said Eleanor Vandermeer, "and I have decided."

She went out. The cane clicked down the steps. In the long gray car, behind the glass, Iris saw her sit very upright with her hands folded in her lap, and then, as the driver pulled away, lift one gloved finger and press it hard against her closed eyes.

Graham Pryce came at noon, with champagne.

He came up the drive in a white convertible, with the top down in spite of the cold, and a bouquet of lilies on the seat beside him. He was forty-two and tanned the year round, with a hundred-watt smile and a gold watch the size of a pocket compass. He kissed her on both cheeks. He said, "Darling, I've been trying to ring since six," and she believed him, and disliked him a little more.

"He's resting."

"Of course he is. God, of course he is. Poor bastard." He put the bottle in her arms. "I won't stay. I only want to see him. I haven't slept. When Sam rang me, I sat down on the kitchen floor and cried like a child."

"Sam Okonkwo called you?"

"He called everyone. It's a small town." The smile did not flicker. "Where is he?"

She took him into the front room.

The man had come down. He sat on the sofa with a blanket across his knees and a cup of tea, looking very pale, and when the visitor came through the door he started, almost imperceptibly, like a rabbit under a shadow.

"Jules!"

Graham crossed the room in three strides and hauled him up off the sofa in a hug. The man's arms hung at his sides for a moment. Then they rose, one at a time, and patted a shoulder, very lightly.

"Jesus Christ," said Graham. "Look at you. You look like death. Welcome back, brother. Welcome back."

"Thank you."

"Not a word. Not a word until you've eaten." He held him at arm's length and clapped his shoulders, grinning with his whole expensive face. "I want to hear everything. Every detail. Where you were, how you got back. Who got to you, I mean, if anyone." He laughed. "But first things first. I've got a few papers to get through. Boring stuff. Firm's been in limbo three years, and the sooner we get you back on the letterhead, the sooner I can stop pretending I'm the senior partner."

"Papers."

"A formality. A power of attorney, so I can unfreeze the operating account. And a one-page affidavit that you're alive." He drew a folded sheaf from his jacket. "Sign here, here, and here."

Iris, in the doorway, with the champagne still in her arms, felt the room tilt.

He had brought the papers. He had had them in his breast pocket, folded in thirds, at noon on the first day, before the man had been home for twelve hours. Before the swab results. Before anyone but a handful of police could have said that Julian Vandermeer was alive.

The man took the pen.

He took it in his left hand. He held it over the first page, over the line marked JULIAN A. VANDERMEER, and Iris saw him stop.

It was a very small stop. A man with amnesia might hesitate over a signature. But she had spent twelve years studying the way a hand makes a mark, the way a pen leans and loads and releases, and she knew that this was not the hesitation of forgetting. It was the hesitation of looking. His eyes were not on the page. They were on a spot just above it, as though he were reading a signature written on the air.

He signed.

She was across the room before she knew she had moved. She did not snatch it. She laid her hand flat on the page, easily, and said, "I'd like to see that."

"Iris, darling, it's just..."

"I know. I'd like to see it."

She tilted the paper to the window.

The V was right. It had Julian's own long vertical stroke, sloping a little to the left, the first stroke of his name for thirty-six years. The J had the loop. The A had the flick. Every letter was in place. And the ink, under the raking light, showed what she had known it would show. The pen had lifted three times in the name. Three small beads of pooled ink where it had paused and begun again, at the joins where Julian's hand had never once stopped in his life.

He had not signed it. He had drawn it.

Slowly, with tremendous care, like a boy copying a map.

"I'll hold on to this," she said. "I'd like to read it first. I don't sign anything I haven't read, and neither does my husband."

For a fraction of a second, Graham Pryce's smile slipped.

It slipped just a quarter inch, no more. The corners of his mouth went flat, and something behind his eyes moved, small and quick and cold. Then it was back, brilliant and white, and he laughed.

"Of course. Of course you will. God, I'd forgotten you were the careful one." He kissed her on the cheek. "Take your time, darling. We have all the time in the world."

He did not look at the man on the sofa as he left. But Iris, watching from the window as the white car backed down the drive, saw the man's hand close around the blanket in his lap until the knuckles went white. His eyes were fixed on the door. And he looked, she thought, like someone who has heard a stair creak in a dark house, and knows exactly whose foot it is.

Posy came home at five, and drew a whale.

She had been given a plain pad of paper and a stub of pencil, and she sat down opposite him at the kitchen table with the air of a customs inspector. She did not say anything. She pushed the pad across. She put her chin on her fists.

"Draw Mister," she said.

"Who?"

"My whale. You said you remembered him."

He looked at her. Then he took the pencil. He bent his head, and for a moment the whole kitchen was quiet except for the scratch of lead on paper.

Iris, at the stove, stirring a pot she wasn't looking at, watched his hand.

It moved easily. That was what struck her first. The line came out in one long sweep, round and warm and unhesitating, the great blunt head and the stubby fin and the single enormous eye. The tail curled up, with a little flick at the tip. It was a lovely drawing. It was alive. It was done in under a minute, as if his hand knew a thing his mind did not.

It was done with his right.

He had taken the pencil without thinking, in the generous forgetfulness of a man drawing for a child, and his wrist had turned the way a wrist turns only when it has done a task ten thousand times. He did not seem to notice. He shaded the underside of the whale. He added the little spout, three curling lines. He put a bubble. Then he glanced up, and saw her face, and saw where she was looking.

He put the pencil down.

He picked it up again, with his left.

"It's good," said Posy, studying it gravely. "It's better than Daddy's. He always made the eye too small."

"I'm sorry."

"Don't be." She took the pad and held it to the light. "I like it."

Iris turned back to the stove.

She did not trust herself to speak. A pot of soup lay in front of her, quietly boiling over, and she stood and watched it with great attention until it ran down the side in a long gold rope and hissed on the burner.

She heard the kitchen door at a quarter to two.

She had been lying fully dressed on top of the covers, with the lamp off and the palette knife on her nightstand, listening to the house settle. She had left Posy asleep with her door ajar. She had checked on her five times. At 1:40 she heard the creak of the third stair, the one that always creaked, taking someone's careful weight.

She went to the window.

The man crossed the lawn in his gray coat. He walked slowly, with the bad leg dragging a track in the frost, and the hood of the coat drawn up over his head. He did not look back. He went straight up the hill through the pale thin moonlight, toward the white stones.

She counted to thirty. Then she took her coat from the hook and a flashlight from the drawer, and she went after him.

She did not turn the light on. The moon was nearly full. The grass was silver, and the maple at the top of the hill stood like a smear of black ink against the sky, and the cold went through the soles of her boots. She kept to the shadow of the stone wall. She moved the way she moved at a bench, carefully, without disturbing anything.

He had stopped at the gate.

He stood a long while with one hand on the iron. Then he went through, and along the gravel, and down the long line of stones to the far end, under the dark bulk of the tree. He knelt. She heard the leather of his coat creak. And in the vast clear silence of the hill, with the town asleep below and the lake a pale pewter plate in the distance, she heard him begin to speak.

"Hello, Theo."

Iris stopped.

She was perhaps thirty feet away, behind the black obelisk of the first Vandermeer. She put her palm flat against the stone. It was cold as a blade.

"I'm sorry I'm late." His voice was low and cracked and tender. It was not Julian's voice. She heard that now, with the plain, terrible clarity of a thing that has been in front of you the whole time. It was higher, and rougher at the edges, with a trace of something in the vowels that Julian never had. A harbor town, maybe. A long way from Vermont. "I know I said I'd come on Sunday. I got held up."

A pause. A small dry sound, like a laugh.

"She took me up here this morning and asked if I remembered you. And I said I didn't." The voice broke. "God forgive me. I looked her in the face and I said, whose is it, was he a cousin?"

The wind moved in the maple.

"He told me everything, you know. Your father. In the last few weeks, when he couldn't sleep, he told me all of it. How she hums the second line. What she was like at twelve. The song your grandmother sang. He told me what he said at the altar. He told me about Poss, and her whale, and the way she says his name when she's upset." The man bent his head. "He told me everything but you."

Iris pressed her fist against her mouth.

"I think it hurt too much. I think you were the one place he couldn't go, even to say it out loud." He drew a long, ragged breath. "So when I came to the door, and I had all those things, I thought, I've got enough. I can do it. I've got her mother's coat and the vows and the tea. I thought I could stand on that porch and be him."

His hand moved over the small white stone.

"But I couldn't do you," said the man at the grave of her son. "I couldn't pretend you, Theo. It was the one thing I couldn't pretend."

She did not know she had moved until the gravel crunched beneath her boot.

He turned.

He was on his knees in the moonlight, with his hood fallen back and his gray beard silver and his face wet, and his eyes in the hollow dark were wide and terrified and utterly naked. For a long moment neither of them breathed.

"Iris," he said.

"Don't call me that."

"Please."

"Who are you?" Her voice shook. She did not care. "Whoever you are, I want it said out loud. Now. On this hill. In front of him."

He rose very slowly, with his hands held out from his sides, and she saw him decide. She saw it happen, as she had seen it happen at the kitchen table, a man deciding to jump into cold water. He opened his mouth.

And somewhere down in the dark at the foot of the hill, behind them both, an engine turned over.

It was a low, smooth, expensive sound. Headlights swung across the trees, slow and white, and swept the long slope of the graveyard like a searchlight. They found the iron gate. They found the gravel path. They found the two figures standing at the far end among the stones.

A car door shut, softly, in the silence.

And a voice, warm, easy, perfectly pleasant, drifted up through the cold.

"There you are. I thought I might find you both up here."