Chapter 2: THE TABLE SET FOR TWO0% read • ~15 min

Chapter 2

THE TABLE SET FOR TWO

15 min read•3,348 words

CHAPTER TWO: THE TABLE SET FOR TWO

"Dev," said Rhea. "My brother. Tall. Nineteen. He drives that green hatchback with the door that won't close unless you slam it twice."

Her mother stood at the stove with the spatula in her hand and her head tilted, wearing the face of someone politely trying to translate a joke from another language.

"Sweetheart," Dana Whitaker said, "you don't have a brother."

The kitchen was very bright. Sun fell across the oak table and its burn mark, and the two plates, and the two glasses of orange juice. A pancake steamed on the plate in front of her. Rhea looked at it, and thought with great clarity that she was about to be sick.

"I do," she said.

"Rhea."

"His name is Dev. He had a tattoo of a bike chain on his wrist. He was in the hospital with you yesterday, he sat in the family room with a bag of chips, he fought with a vending machine." Her voice was climbing, and she could not stop it. "You told him his haircut looked like a cry for help."

Her mother put the spatula down. She crossed the kitchen and took Rhea's face in both hands, her palms warm and dry and strong, a nurse's hands, hands that had not been strong since February.

"My love," she said gently. "Look at me. Whatever you dreamed last night, it wasn't real. You've been so frightened these months, and I know I haven't made it easy. But it's been the two of us for a long time. Just us."

Rhea stared at her.

There was nothing in her mother's face but love and puzzlement. No flicker. No guilt. Nothing hidden behind it. A person who is lying has a seam, a place the light catches wrongly, and Rhea had spent her whole life learning to see them. There was no seam. Her mother simply did not know.

"The scan," Rhea whispered.

"Oh." The whole face changed. It lit from inside like a window at dusk. "Oh, baby, I haven't told you. Dr. Okafor called at seven. I picked up the phone in my nightgown, I was shaking like a leaf." She laughed and wiped her eye with her thumb. "Clean. Every last bit of it. She said she's never seen a result like it. She said, I don't have a word, Dana. I said, neither do I."

She pulled Rhea into her arms.

It was the best thing Rhea had ever felt. She would remember that for the rest of her life, with a shame that never fully dried. Her mother's heartbeat, strong and steady against her ear. The smell of butter and cinnamon and clean cotton. The long braid, thick and silver-streaked, brushing her wrist. She stood in her mother's arms, and she was so happy she thought she might break, and in the same breath she knew she had killed someone to get it.

"I want to go upstairs," she said into her mother's shoulder.

"Of course. Eat first."

"I will. In a minute."

She went up the stairs one at a time, with her hand on the rail.

Dev's room was at the top of the landing, on the left, a door with a dent in the bottom panel from the time he kicked it for dramatic effect. She put her hand on the knob. She told herself she knew what was behind it. A bed with a rumpled gray duvet, a shelf of bike manuals, a pile of greasy jeans, the lamp with the bent neck.

She opened the door.

It was her mother's sewing room.

A cutting table. A dress form wearing half a blue skirt. Shelves of fabric, folded in rainbow order, and a machine under a quilted cover with a pincushion shaped like a tomato. The window looked out over the same maple. The wallpaper was the same pale green. It had always been green.

She stood in the doorway and did not breathe.

Then she went in. She dropped to her hands and knees and pressed her palm flat on the floorboards. She found the long scratch near the radiator, the one Dev made dragging his weights across the room when he was fifteen, a pale scar in the varnish as long as her forearm. She followed it with her finger. It was there. It was exactly where it had always been, a groove in the wood, and nobody had put it there.

A small, hard sound came out of her throat.

She searched the whole house in twenty minutes.

The hall photographs showed her at five, at nine, at fourteen, grinning in front of a crooked Christmas tree. Always alone. Always a little to one side, with a gap beside her where an arm should have gone around her shoulders, though the gap was so slight that nobody looking would have noticed. The garage held one car. In the driveway, on the concrete, was a patch of dark oil, long and thin and old, in the exact shape of a car that was no longer parked there.

She stood over it with her arms wrapped around herself.

On the way back through the hall she caught sight of herself in the mirror. A tall, pale girl in an enormous denim jacket, frayed at the collar, cuffs folded back three times. She had slept in it. She had not taken it off. She looked down.

The jacket was still there.

It should not have been. It was Dev's. The world had forgotten him, and it had cleared away the car and the room and every photograph in the house, and it had forgotten to take this. She put both hands in the pockets.

In the left one, her fingers closed on something small and crinkly. She drew it out.

A wrapped ginger candy. The kind he carried for their mother when the nausea was bad, the cheap kind from the bin at the pharmacy, gone slightly soft from the warmth of his body. A small gold wrapper with a dent in the corner.

Rhea held it in her fist, and she sat down on the bottom stair, and she let herself cry.

She called Noor at ten.

It was a school day. Her mother had said, stay home, love, you've had a shock, in the tone of a woman who had been given a second life and meant to spend all of it with her daughter in the same room. Rhea took the phone out to the back step, where the wind carried the sound of the maple, and dialed the only number she knew by heart.

"Hey, you," said Noor. A clatter of cutlery behind her. "Skiving? Brave. Is it the mom thing? Did the scan..."

"It's clean."

A shriek. "Shut up. Shut up! Rhea! Oh my God, where are you, I'm coming over, I'll bring the chocolate, I have chocolate in my bag, don't move..."

"Noor. Wait."

"What?"

"Do you remember my brother?"

The cutlery stopped. In the long pause that followed, Rhea heard a hundred small lunchroom sounds, and she thought: please. Please. I'll never ask for anything again.

"Your what?" said Noor.

"Dev."

"Rhea." Noor's voice had changed. It had gone careful, the voice she used for a friend standing too close to the edge of a platform. "Hon. You don't have a brother."

"He's nineteen. He works at Spoke and Wheel. He's the one who taught us to ride, you fell off in the cemetery and he laughed so hard he had to sit down."

"I fell off by myself. Your mom held the back of the seat."

"No. That's..."

"Are you doing a bit?"

"No."

"Because it's okay if you are, I mean, I'd get it." She hesitated. "You wrote about him once. Remember? In third grade. We had to write a letter to somebody we wished we had, and you wrote a whole page about an older brother who'd fix your bike and walk you home. You made it so real, Mrs. Pruitt cried. You said you'd tell him everything." A breath. "Hon. That's all it ever was. You always wanted one so badly."

Rhea closed her eyes.

It was the cruelest thing the notebook had done. It had not simply taken him. It had reached back and gone through the whole of her life, picking out every wish and every gap, and fitted them together, so that Noor's memory had room for an imaginary boy and no room for the real one.

"Okay," she said. "Okay. Yeah. Sorry. I think I'm just tired."

"You're allowed."

"Yeah."

"I'm coming over."

"You don't have to."

"Rhea," said Noor. "I'm bringing the chocolate."

She sat on the back step, with the phone in her lap and her knees drawn up, and watched a squirrel climb the maple.

The Alder Falls Public Library opened at one on Tuesdays. Rhea was standing on the steps at five to, with the black notebook in the inside pocket of the denim jacket. She had told her mother she was going for a walk. She had been told to take her scarf.

Mr. Finch unlocked the door himself.

He stood in the gloom of the vestibule in his gray cardigan with a ring of keys in one hand. He did not say Miss Whitaker. He did not say good afternoon. He only looked at her for a long moment, at her red eyes and the too-large jacket and the way she held her arms across her ribs, and something in his long face gave way.

"Oh, my dear," he said. "Who did you lose?"

She had meant to be angry. She had spent the whole bus ride rehearsing it. You knew. You stood there in the aisle and you let me walk out with it. But the words had gone, and what came out of her mouth was a small, cracked voice that did not sound like hers.

"My brother."

"Ah." He nodded slowly, as if she had told him the time. "Come inside. I'll put the kettle on."

The librarian's office was a narrow room behind the reference desk, with a green-shaded lamp and a card catalog that no one had used in thirty years. A kettle hummed on a hot plate. Mr. Finch poured two cups of tea into mismatched china, and put one in front of her, and sat down across the desk with his hands folded.

On the blotter between them lay a framed photograph of a woman. Silver hair, a wide mouth, a scarf the color of marigolds. She was laughing at something just out of frame. Mr. Finch had turned the photograph a little away from himself, so that he would not see it, and a little toward the door, so that anyone coming in would.

"My wife," he said. "June. We were married forty-one years."

"Was?"

"Is. I never know which." He took off his spectacles and pressed his thumb and finger into the corners of his eyes. "She had a stroke in the spring of nineteen ninety-six. I was fifty-one. She lived eleven days. I sat in a room very much like the one at St. Brigid's, with a very large nurse, and I thought: it's a sentence. It's only a sentence. If I could only find the right words."

Rhea set down her tea.

"I found the notebook in the returns," he said. "It was a Thursday. I had worked here for twenty years and I had never seen it before. And on the first page, in a hand I did not know, there was a note. Don't."

"Mine said that too."

"They always do. A different hand each time. I think each one of us writes it to the next." His mouth trembled, very slightly. "I wrote June well. I wrote that she woke up and knew me and was strong. I had never written anything so carefully in my life."

"And?"

"And she woke up. She sat up in bed and asked for a cup of tea." He smiled, terribly. "She lived another nine years. We went to Portugal. She taught me to dance badly. And then one morning in October, in two thousand and five, I woke up and the other side of the bed was cold, and I went downstairs and there was a woman standing in my kitchen, making coffee. A stranger. Very kind. She said she was my wife."

Rhea stared at him.

"It does not take what you ask," said Mr. Finch. "It takes what it needs. It collected, you see, on an old debt. Nine years of interest. It did not take June. It took the world's memory of June." He turned the photograph a fraction further toward the door. "That is the cleverest part. It leaves you the one who remembers. It leaves you to carry it."

"Where is she?"

"I don't know."

"Mr. Finch..."

"I have looked for twenty-one years." He said it quite gently. "I have read every book in this building. I have written to people in six countries. I know the names of the other readers, going back to eighteen sixty-three, because they are in the back of the ledger, and I know what became of nearly every one." A pause. "Some of them found a way. Some did not. The ones who did, I could not follow."

"There's a way?"

"There is always a way. That is the other cruelty of it." His eyes met hers, red-rimmed and tired and very kind. "Rhea. May I tell you the single thing I know?"

"Yes."

"You have until Sunday."

The kettle clicked off. In the little room it sounded very loud.

"It keeps them for seven nights," said Mr. Finch. "The erased. They are not dead. They are somewhere the notebook holds. It is like a coat in a cloakroom, I believe, with a ticket. Seven nights. And after the seventh the ticket goes, and the coat goes with it, and there is nothing left of them anywhere. Not in the notebook. Not in the world. Not even in you." He folded his hands. "I let the seventh night pass. I did not know. I was in a hospital in Lisbon, and I had written a cheerful sentence about going home, and I never knew that the clock was running."

Her tea had gone cold in her hand.

"You said there's a way."

"I did."

"What is it?"

"I don't know, my dear. I never worked it out." He reached across the blotter, and for the first time he touched her, very lightly, on the back of the wrist. His hand was papery and cold. "But I know this much. It will not let you undo what you wrote. It permits only one thing. Trade. And the trade is always in kind, and always in the shape of what you love the most."

"I already traded."

"No. You made a purchase." The ghost of a smile. "A trade is something you choose."

"I don't want to trade anything. I want my brother back."

"Of course you do." He let go. "Go home, Rhea. Read the margins. It writes its own rules, you know, a little at a time, as it decides you can bear them. I have never read the third. I believe it only shows itself to those who are ready." He lifted the photograph and held it a moment, and set it down, with its face to the door. "And whatever you do, don't write anything that begins with he."

Dana Whitaker had made supper. Chicken and rice, and green beans with almonds, and a chocolate cake with a cherry on top that she had baked at three in the afternoon in a kitchen full of sun, humming, with flour on her cheek. She set the table. She lit the candle. She put out two plates.

Rhea ate. She said it was delicious. She smiled in the right places. When her mother laughed at something and reached across the table to squeeze her hand, she squeezed back. And all through the meal, she felt the weight of the notebook against her ribs, as heavy as a second heartbeat.

At nine she said she was tired. Her mother kissed her on the forehead. "My love," she said. "I'm so glad you're here."

"Me too."

"I mean it. I'm so glad."

"I know, Mom."

She climbed the stairs. She went into her bedroom and shut the door and sat on the bed. She took out the notebook, and set it on her knees, and opened it, and began to read the margins by the light of the little lamp.

It had written there.

She had not noticed it that morning, in the haze of the pancakes. But in the narrow white strip down the left side of the first page, in small blue letters that were not there yesterday, her own hand had set down three short lines.

RULE ONE: EVERYTHING WRITTEN IS TRUE.
RULE TWO: EVERYTHING TRUE IS PAID FOR.
RULE THREE:

A colon. And then a blank.

She stared at the empty space. As she watched, faint letters began to rise through the paper, gray as breath on a window. A word. Part of a word. The ink moved, uncertain, and thinned, and sank back out of sight. It tried again. It tried a third time, and failed. The line stayed blank.

She turned to the last leaf.

The ledger had grown. Under Bethany Marsh and a hundred other names, in a column of faded entries, there was a new one at the bottom, in her own blue hand.

Devlin Whitaker. Brother. 1 of 7.

Her breath went out of her all at once.

She sat for a long time with her thumb on the line. The ink was fresh. It was still faintly damp, and beside the number, a very small mark had been drawn in the margin, like a tally scratched on a prison wall.

Six nights.

She turned off the lamp. She lay on top of the covers in her clothes, with Dev's jacket still around her shoulders and the ginger candy held tight in her fist, and stared at the dark ceiling. The house settled. Down in the kitchen, her mother was washing dishes, humming. Out on Linden Street, a car went by, and its lights crossed the ceiling and were gone.

At some point she must have slept.

She woke because something was wrong.

It took her a minute to understand what it was. The house was silent. Her mother had gone to bed. The clock on her nightstand said 2:07. The streetlamp threw a pale square on the floor. And through the wall at the head of her bed, from the room next door, the room that had been a sewing room all her life, a sound had begun.

Knock.

A single dull rap, knuckle on plaster, from the other side of the wall.

She lay perfectly still. Her heart had stopped.

Knock.

Two. Slow and careful, with a space between, as if someone were waiting to see whether she would answer.

She sat up. The jacket slid off her shoulder. She pressed her palm against the wall at the head of the bed, and the plaster was cold. Across it, very faintly, she could feel a vibration, a hum through the stud, like a person leaning their whole weight against the other side.

Knock.

Three.

That was the rule. That was the thing they had done since she was six years old and afraid of the dark. Three knocks, on the wall between their rooms, so that she would know he was there. She had never needed to knock back. He always answered first.

Rhea put her mouth against the plaster.

"Dev?" she whispered.

And from the other side of the wall, thin and far away, as if it were coming up from the bottom of a very deep well, a voice she knew better than her own said:

"Dictionary. Don't write anything else."

Rewrote Her Own Ending — Chapter 2: THE TABLE SET FOR TWO | BlueNov