Chapter 5: Knock Back0% read • ~16 min

Chapter 5

Knock Back

16 min read•3,615 words

The pen wrote her name in her own hand, and Rhea could not stop it.

She stood at the open doors of the ambulance with the red and blue lights turning across her face, and her fingers moved over the page without her. R. H. E. A. The nib dragged. The ink ran fat and glossy. It was her handwriting exactly, the crossed sevens, the g that looped twice, and she thought with a terrible clear calm that this was what it must be like to watch someone else sign your name on a check.

Rhea Whitaker.

A comma. Then more.

She did not read it as it came. She read it all at once when it was done, in the strobing light, with her mother's gurney rattling past her elbow.

Rhea Whitaker is the one who paid. She is gone, and no one remembers her. Devlin Whitaker comes home. Dana Whitaker stays well.

It was not a threat. That was what she understood, standing there. It was an offer. The notebook had looked at the whole terrible arithmetic, her mother's body failing, her brother in a hallway of paper doors, a girl who could not stop editing, and it had found a way to balance every column. Her mother cured. Dev back. Noor with her cousin who did not exist. Everyone she loved, whole and warm and happy.

And herself, nowhere.

"Rhea." Noor's voice, high and thin, a long way off. "Rhea, don't. Don't touch the pen."

"I'm not touching it."

"Then why are you writing?"

"I'm not." Her hand was cramping. Her thumb ached where the pen pressed into it. She wrenched her wrist sideways, and the nib skidded off the page in a long black streak, and she threw the fountain pen down onto the wet road. It rolled under the ambulance and lay there.

The ink on the page went on drying.

"Miss?" said the paramedic. "We have to go."

"Coming."

She shut the notebook. It was warm. It was warm like a living thing, and it pulsed once against her ribs, patiently, the way a dog thumps its tail on a floor when it knows you will come back.

"Tumor markers are back," said Dr. Okafor.

It was past midnight. She was a small, composed woman in a long white coat, and she stood at the foot of the bed in Bay Six with a tablet held against her chest, as if it might protect her. Dana lay propped on three pillows in a gown that was too big for her, with an oxygen tube in her nose and the bright, hectic flush gone completely from her face. Her braid had been loosened. Under the strip lights it looked like silver wire.

"I'll be honest," said Dr. Okafor, and she looked at Rhea when she said it, not at the bed. "I have never seen this. We scanned her yesterday, and there was nothing. Not a shadow. Tonight there is a mass in the left lung and another near the liver, and the scan could pass for six months of growth." She stopped. "I don't have a word for it."

"That's what you said yesterday," Dana whispered.

"It is."

"You said you didn't have a word, Dana."

"I did." A very small smile. "I'm becoming repetitive."

"Is it treatable?" Rhea's voice came out cracked.

"We have options. A trial at Hopkins, a combination we haven't tried." Dr. Okafor hesitated. "I won't tell you it is simple. But your mother is a fighter, and you are not alone."

Rhea thought: I am. She thought: that's the thing nobody can tell you.

When the doctor had gone, Dana turned her head on the pillow. She looked at her daughter for a long while. In the strip light her eyes were hazel and enormous.

"Come here, my love."

Rhea went. She sat on the edge of the bed, and her mother took her hand in both of hers. Her skin was dry and papery. A gold wrapper crackled in the pocket of her gown.

"I've been very happy this week," Dana said. "I want you to know that."

"Mom."

"No, listen. I woke up on Tuesday and I thought, this is the best I have ever felt. And I could not understand why I was so sad." She smiled. "There was a space beside me. I kept reaching for it. Like a person who's lost a tooth." Her thumb moved over Rhea's knuckles. "Whatever you did, I'm not angry. I don't know what it was. But I know you did it because you loved me."

Rhea could not speak.

"I would like to ask one thing." Her mother's grip tightened. "If it can be undone, I would like you to undo it."

"Mom, if I undo it, you..."

"I know."

"You'll be sick."

"I'm sick now." She said it quite simply. "I would rather be sick with whoever I forgot than well without him." Her eyes shone. "Isn't that odd? I don't even know his name."

The ginger candy crackled again in her pocket. And down in Rhea's chest something, long clenched, began very slowly to loosen.

She found Mr. Finch in the chapel.

It was a small, bare room at the end of the second floor, with eight pews and a window of colored glass, lit by a single lamp. He sat in the back pew in his gray cardigan with his hat on his knee and the green cloth book open beside him. Noor was beside him. They had not been speaking. They had the look of two people who had been very quiet together for a long time.

"I let myself in," he said. "I hope that is not an imposition. I thought a person might want somewhere to sit."

"It's fine."

"Miss Siddiqui told me about the ambulance."

"It tried to write my name."

"Yes." He nodded slowly. "It does that. It is, I think, the thing it has been building toward. It wants a reader who will give it everything." He closed the green book. "It is not malice, I believe. It is hunger. It has been alone a very long time."

Rhea sat down in the pew in front of them and turned to face him. The lamp hummed. A moth beat against the colored glass.

"You said nine of them drew a line."

"Yes."

"A straight line. Across the bottom of the page."

"At the end of their ink. Yes."

"Do you know what that is?"

"I confess, I never worked it out."

"It's what you do at the end of a ledger." She heard her own voice grow quick, as it did when she found a better sentence. "When you've balanced the accounts. You rule off. You draw a line under the last entry, so no one can add to it. It's an accountant's mark. My dad used to do it in the kitchen on Sundays, with a ruler."

Noor sat up.

"It closes the account," Rhea said. "That's all. It doesn't erase anyone. It just says, nothing more can be written here."

"Then the nine didn't die," whispered Noor.

"I don't think so. I think they ended their own part of the book." She had begun to shake. "Rule Three says, to unwrite a sentence the writer must write her own ending. I've been reading it wrong. I thought it meant the end of me. But it's not the end of me. It's mine. Whatever I write. If I write the ending, then I get to choose the way it ends."

"What would you write?" said Mr. Finch.

She looked at the colored glass. A saint, or a shepherd. It was too dark to say.

"That I stop," she said.

"Stop."

"Writing." Her mouth shook. "Everything. Not just the book. Every ending I've been trying to control since I was eleven. Dad. Mom. Dev. Every diary. The whole habit of it. The way I tried to hold the world still by putting the right sentence on it." She wiped her eyes. "I've been editing my life since I was a child, and I never once let it be a draft."

"And the book?"

"It's the same. It's only the same, grown larger." She took the black notebook out of the canvas bag and laid it on the pew. "If I rule off the last page, it can't take another reader. I don't know what happens to the names in it. I don't know what happens to the sentences. I think..." She swallowed. "I think they end. All of them. The cure, too."

Nobody spoke.

"Mom's scan," said Noor.

"Yes."

"Rhea. If you close it, she..."

"I know."

"She's already..."

"She's sick, Noor. She's sick right now, and she asked me to." She was crying freely. "She doesn't remember him, and she said she'd rather be sick with him than well without him. She doesn't even know his name."

Mr. Finch had taken off his spectacles.

"I did not have the courage," he said. "I want you to know that, whatever happens. I never will. But I will tell you what I think I know, Miss Whitaker. A cure that costs a person her whole life is not a cure. It is a postponement." His voice was very gentle. "June lived nine years because of what I wrote. They were the best nine years I have had. And I would trade every one of them, tonight, to know that I had let her go when it was time."

"But you'd get her back."

"I would get her back," he said, "in a world where I had earned it."

The clock in the corridor struck two.

It was a small, flat, institutional stroke, and the second the sound ended, she knew what the time was. 2:07. She had seen it on her bedside clock every night for a week. The knock had always come at 2:07.

On the pew beside her, the notebook began to hum.

She wrote it in the chapel.

She sat in the front pew with the book open on her knee, and Noor on her left and Mr. Finch on her right, and the lamp turned low. She had no pen. She had thrown it under an ambulance. She put out her hand without knowing why, and from the shadow under the next pew, as if it had been waiting there all along, a plain black fountain pen with a chipped cap rolled gently into her palm.

It was warm. The nib was wet.

She did not hurry. She turned to the last page, the leaf of ledger with its hundred and sixty-one names. Below the last entry, Devlin Whitaker, Brother, 3 of 7, she left a gap the width of a hand. Then she took a long breath and put the nib to the paper, and wrote her own sentence, slowly and carefully, in the careful block capitals she used for things that mattered.

I am Rhea Whitaker. I am sixteen. I do not know how this ends.

The ink sank in at once, and the page went warm.

I will not write the ending of anyone I love again.

The lamp flickered.

I give back every sentence I wrote. I give back every name this book has kept. Let them go home.

She stopped. Her hand trembled so much that she had to steady it with the other. In her pocket, the fabric of Dev's jacket brushed her ribs, and she thought of a boy on a staircase, tearing a letter in half, saying very softly I won't come in. But if you want, you can knock back.

She wrote the last line.

This is the last thing written here. The End.

She put a ruler line beneath it, one hard stroke, left to right, the way her father had done on Sundays at the kitchen table.

Nothing happened.

Then everything did.

The ink on the page lit from within. It did not flare or burn. It brightened, as a window does when someone lights a lamp behind a curtain, a soft blue glow, steady and clean. The light rose off the paper in a column and spread through the chapel like water, and the whole room filled with it. And in the light there were names.

They rose out of the ledger one at a time, hundreds of them, small and bright, drifting up like lanterns. Bethany Marsh. Walter Aldous. Mei-Ling Tan. A woman called Constance Wray, 1863. A child's name in a spidery print. They went up past the colored window and through the plaster and out into the night, and where they passed, a warmth followed, as though a door had opened somewhere in the world on a long-closed room.

"Oh," said Mr. Finch.

A single name rose last, higher and brighter than the rest. JUNE ELLEN FINCH. It hung above the pew, a small blue star, and in its light the old man's face was wholly bare. He did not say anything. He stood, with his hat in his hands, and the star turned once, as if in a slow dance step, and went out through the wall.

"She's going to be so annoyed," he said, in a cracked and radiant voice. "I haven't practiced."

Rhea put the pen down.

It was dust in her palm. It crumbled as she touched it, a pinch of gray ash that smelled of burned sugar, and she brushed it off on her knee. The black notebook lay open beside her. Every page was white. Not blank. White, the clean pale white of a thing that has never been written on, and the cloth cover was only cloth, the red spine pale as a rose.

She held it in her lap. She could feel nothing in it. No pulse. No hunger.

It was only a book.

And down the corridor, through the open chapel door, from the direction of Bay Six, came the sound of a woman's thin voice, rising in alarm.

"Who's that? Who is that? There's a boy in my..."

Then a second voice, rough and warm and a little out of breath. "Mom?"

Rhea was on her feet.

She did not remember the corridor. She remembered the squeak of her sneakers on the lino, and Noor running behind her, and the swinging doors of Bay Six, and the whole bright room tilted sideways by the speed of her arrival. She remembered the green hatchback keys on the bedside table. The grease under the fingernails. The shaggy brown hair standing up on one side, and the bike chain around the right wrist, and the old pair of boots, and a nineteen-year-old boy in a flannel shirt, sitting on the edge of their mother's hospital bed with both his hands wrapped around hers.

He looked up.

The crooked grin broke across his face like a door thrown open.

"Hey, Dictionary," said Dev. "I told you not to write anything else."

She hit him in the chest so hard that he fell back against the pillows. Then she was on the bed too, with her arms around his neck, her face in his shoulder, her tears soaking straight through the flannel. He smelled of ink and chain oil and the particular warm smell of her own childhood. He held her with one arm. The other was around their mother.

"I wrote one more," she said. She could barely get it out. "I'm sorry. Just one."

"I know. I heard the pen." His voice cracked. "It's okay. It's all right. I was there for most of it, kid. I read it over your shoulder."

"How?"

"Walls are thin." He laughed, a wet, scraped sound. "I knocked."

Their mother was crying too. She had both of them by the collar, and she kept saying his name, Devlin, Devlin, Dev, as if she were learning it in a language she had spoken all her life. "I knew," she kept saying. "I knew. I knew there was someone. I couldn't find your face. Oh, my baby."

She pulled the ginger candy out of her pocket.

It lay on her palm, small and gold and dented. She looked at it. She looked at him. And then, very slowly, with an expression of the purest wonder, she began to laugh.

"It was you," she said. "You put them in my coat."

"Every winter," said Dev.

"I thought it was the heater."

"It was never the heater, Mom."

Noor stood in the doorway with both hands over her mouth. She did not make a sound. She only stood there with her silver rings glittering and her hijab slipping off her ear, and then she crossed the room in four strides and punched Dev in the arm, hard, and burst into tears.

"I remembered your boots," she sobbed. "You gave me boots. You said I'd grow into them. I grew into them!"

"I told you."

"You're an idiot."

"I'm a great deal of an idiot," said Dev, and pulled her in.

The cancer did not go away.

It never does, in real life, not all at once. Dr. Okafor said so, clearly and kindly, at nine the next morning, with the trial papers spread on a tray table and the sun climbing the wall. The mass in the lung was real. So was the one by the liver. The treatment would be hard. There would be good days and terrible days, and some of them would come without warning.

"But I have to say," said Dr. Okafor, and she took off her glasses, "there is one thing. This is the best-looking tumor I have ever seen. It's responding like a textbook." She put them back on. "I wouldn't tell Dana, but I think she's going to be very annoying about it."

"She's already annoying," said Dev.

"Thank you, Dev," said their mother, from the bed. "I can hear you."

They did the next thing.

That was what Dev said, and it was what they did. They did it for six months of chemotherapy and one rotten Christmas. Dev went back to Spoke and Wheel, and then, in March, quietly, to the community college on Fenwick Street, where a woman at the admissions desk found a file that had been sitting for two years and said, "We never could bring ourselves to throw it out." Noor kept coming on Tuesdays with chocolate. Rhea slept on the couch in the hospital room, and she sat through the long afternoons with a blanket over her knees and nothing in her hands.

That was the strangest part. She did not write.

She had thought she would miss it. She had thought it would be like losing a limb. But every time her fingers closed on a pen they simply opened again, and she sat there with the afternoon light in her lap and watched the nurses walk by and listened to her brother tell a joke too loudly. The ending did not come. There was always another next thing. She had never known that was possible.

One Saturday in April she went to the library.

It was a bright, windy day, and the gingko in the Reading Garden had come into its first soft green. The fountain was running. There were two benches out in the sun, and on the farthest one an old man in a gray cardigan sat with a woman in a marigold scarf. They were not talking. They were holding hands and watching a pigeon. As Rhea came through the arch, the woman turned her head, and her whole wide mouth lit up.

"Oh, there she is," said June Finch. "The girl with the pen."

"I don't have a pen anymore."

"No." She smiled. "Good. Abel, move over. She'll want to sit."

"I'm moving, I'm moving. You know I cannot move on command."

"You've never once moved on command in forty-one years."

"I've never needed to." He shifted and gave Rhea a long, brimming look, and she saw that he was crying, quite calmly, as a man cries who has been rained on for twenty years and has finally come in. He did not say thank you. He took her hand in both of his, in the dappled sun, and they all sat for a while and watched the fountain.

"We're going dancing tonight," said June. "He's terrible."

"I'm improving."

"He is not."

"I am slightly."

"He's learned to count."

In the end, Rhea went home on the bus. She sat by the window. She had a small blank notebook in her bag, a cheap green one with a spiral spine, bought at the pharmacy for two dollars, and she took it out and set it on her knee and looked at the first page.

It was ruled in pale blue, with a red margin. It was absolutely empty.

She did not uncap anything. She thought for a long time about the words she might put there. A date. A line. A sentence about how it feels to sit in the sun. And she knew, with a quiet that was almost joy, that she would not write the ending. She would only begin, and see where it went.

That night, in her bedroom on Linden Street, with the window open to the sound of Dev's bad singing through the wall, she turned off her lamp and lay in the dark.

For a minute, nothing.

Then, from the other side of the plaster, a small, familiar sound. Knuckles on a wall.

Knock.

Knock.

Knock.

She smiled in the dark. She put out her hand, and she did not wait for him to answer first. She knocked back.

THE END