Chapter 18: A LAKE WITHOUT TIDES0% read • ~7 min

Chapter 18

A LAKE WITHOUT TIDES

7 min read•1,500 words

Lake Superior has no tides worth the name. A few inches, a rumor, the pull of the moon on a body too big to answer it. Wren told me that at thirty-eight thousand feet while the plane ate its way across the dark, and then she was quiet for so long I thought she’d fallen asleep.

“Rose’s slack is the time she left,” she said finally. “I told her, you need an hour. She chose it herself. Four fifty-five. She said she wanted to be on a bus before the milkman.” A short, dry sound. “Nobody in Duluth ever looks at the water at four fifty-five. The tide doesn’t give you any reason.”

I sat in the window seat with my forehead against the cold plastic. Eli slept across the aisle with his mouth open and his hat in his lap, and I watched him for a moment the way you watch a lit fuse. In my pocket, folded into thirds, lay the bus ticket. Priya had let me keep it. She had also given me a hotel voucher, a detective’s name, and a look that said she intended to hold my license hostage if I got anyone killed.

“Say what you’re not saying,” Wren said.

“I’m not saying anything.”

“You’re chewing a cinnamon toothpick that you took out of your pocket three minutes ago, and you’ve counted the exits twice. You do this.”

I took it out of my mouth. It had gone to pulp.

“Marnie,” I said.

Wren turned toward me in her seat. Her grey eyes were steady and tired.

“I keep thinking,” I said, “that if I hadn’t come home. If I hadn’t been dragged back by a jacket. She’d have gone to the Tidehouse on Tuesday and Quill would have helped her, and she’d be alive. I’m the reason somebody put it on a stranger. I’m the reason Dale wanted me in that town.” I could hear my voice going quiet, the transformer hum. “She was a paralegal. She drafted policies. She did one brave thing in her life and the one person she told was you, and then I got her killed.”

“Nor-Nor.”

“I’m not asking to be forgiven. I’m saying it out loud so it’s logged.”

Wren was silent. The engines droned. Somewhere ahead a baby began to cry, cranky and thin.

“Marnie was twenty-nine,” she said. “She wanted to open a pottery studio. She made me a mug once with a crooked handle, and I said, what’s wrong with the handle, and she said, character.” Her mouth moved. “She told me about you when we first met. She said, your sister’s the cleanest investigator at the firm. She said, she’s so careful, I think she’s scared of her own questions.”

“She wasn’t wrong.”

“She wasn’t.” Wren’s hand found mine on the armrest and held it, hard. “She also said you were the only person at Ames and Pellam who ever once gave her a straight answer. She used to leave you paperwork she wanted you to see. You never noticed.”

I thought of the file on my desk the week Raske closed. The tidy witnesses. The perfect log. A yellow sticky note I’d thrown away without reading, because it wasn’t signed. I had assumed it was a clerk’s reminder.

“What did it say?” Wren asked, watching my face.

“I don’t remember. Something about the dock. I thought it meant the boat’s dock.”

She closed her eyes. “Then she tried.”

“Yes.”

“That’s what I wanted you to know,” my sister said. “That she tried and she was good at it. And that the person who killed her has a name that isn’t yours.”

We landed at four in the morning in Minneapolis, in a drizzle the color of old nickels, and drove the rental north in a silence we had earned. Eli took the wheel without asking. In the rearview mirror his face looked younger and tireder than I’d ever seen it, and when I caught his eye he looked away.

“You said nine,” I said.

He gripped the wheel. “I did.”

“You told me five.”

“Four were children.” His voice dropped. “Dale never put it that way. He called them runners. A woman and a boy, a woman and two girls. I rowed them out to the Reach where the launch picked them up. I was told, drop them at the ledge by the Lung. I never saw the Lung. I only saw a flash of light, and they were gone.” He swallowed. “I think Tom Vance built it for them. I think they were safe. I think those four were the real ones.”

“You think.”

“I’m trying to hold onto it.”

I looked out the window. Pine and black water, the endless north. “Then hold it. We’ll find out which of the nine were real.”

Duluth came up out of the dark like a city drawn by a child, hills stacked on hills and the lake behind them, a black plain going on forever under a sky with no stars. The street lamps on Superior Street made yellow pools in the rain. At 4:20 AM the bakery’s window was lit.

Detective Amara Okafor of the Duluth Police met us on the sidewalk in a green slicker. She was small, brisk, forty or so, with a braid under her hood and a voice like a ruler. “No one inside,” she said. “No sign of struggle past the overturned chair. Two patrol cars on Lake Avenue. I’ve got a team behind the building. You’ll go in one at a time, you’ll touch nothing, and you’ll stay in my sight.”

“Understood.”

“Say it back.”

I stopped.

“Say it back,” said Okafor, impatient. “I’m told that’s a thing the Vances do.”

I glanced at Wren. She’d gone red to the ears. “Priya talks too much,” she muttered.

“Don’t touch anything,” I said.

The bakery was warm. That was the first thing. A real, living warmth, flour and cardamom and yeast, ovens ticking as they cooled. A chalkboard menu on the wall, written in a round cheerful hand. A glass case of buns. On the floor near the register, an apron with a scorched hem lay in a loop like something dropped by a runner.

I stood in the doorway counting. Front door, back door, a stair to a room above, a skylight, a cellar hatch in the floor behind the counter, the lid ajar. Five.

“The cellar,” said Wren, close to my ear. “The Landing keeps a room under every shop. She’ll have used it.”

“Okafor.”

“Cleared. Empty.” She crouched at the hatch with her flashlight. “Except for this.”

The beam lit a flight of wooden stairs, a concrete floor, and at the bottom a folding table with a single chair. On the table sat a laptop, closed, and beside it a thermos, a paper plate with a half-eaten cardamom bun, and a note.

I went down. Okafor didn’t stop me. I knew every step before I put my foot on it, and I knew why.

The note was written on a bakery order pad, in a round, careful, tired hand. It had been written fast. The last line ran off the edge of the paper.

Nora Vance. If you’re reading this you’re the clever one. I took the apron off so they’d think I ran. I didn’t. They came at 3 and I was already in the walk-in. I heard them say they were waiting for the sisters. A woman with iron hair said she’d be back at slack. I don’t know what slack is in this town. I only know I have to be on a bus before milkman. If you’re reading this and you are not a woman with iron hair, please turn around.

Below it, in smaller letters:

The laptop is not mine.

I looked at the closed machine. Wren had come down behind me. She stood at my shoulder with her arms wrapped around herself, and I felt rather than heard her stop breathing.

Okafor’s radio crackled upstairs.

“Detective,” said a flat voice in the static, “we have a car on Superior. Gray sedan, no plate. It’s been circling the block for ten minutes. Driver’s a woman, sixty, gray hair. She just parked at the front.”

I lifted the laptop lid.

The screen woke on a live video feed. A kitchen, shot from a shelf, from slightly above. A plaid couch. A coffee tin on a counter. A woman with a silver braid, sitting at a table, hands flat on the oilcloth, face turned toward the lens.

My mother. At our kitchen table in Ashgrove Bay. Looking straight at the camera, and, I understood, straight at me.

The time stamp in the corner read 4:49. Six minutes.

And standing behind her chair, just inside the frame, a hand on the back of it, in a camel coat and a clean white shirt, a man who ought to have been at the bottom of the Atlantic smiled gently into the lens.