Chapter 12
REYES FAMILY KITCHEN
Julian drove. Nobody had agreed to that. It simply happened, the way weather happens, because he was holding the keys and Noah did not trust himself with them.
Noah sat beside him with his hands pressed between his knees. I took the back seat, with Walter’s coat folded across my lap and the little hard rectangle of the drive sewn into its lining, and the prepaid phone glowing at twenty-two percent against my thigh. Behind us, the lake house burned gold through the pines until the trees closed over it.
My parents had stayed. That had been the third door too. Richard would keep Thomas talking, and my mother would keep Walter alive, and Margaret, gray and shaking, had taken the nurse’s number and a kitchen knife. Thomas had let us go with a small, courteous nod. Eight minutes, he’d said, and every one of them was now a held breath.
“Where?” Noah asked, for the third time.
“You won’t like it.”
“I don’t like any of it.”
“It’s closer to the city than the lake.” Julian’s eyes did not leave the road. “I’ll tell you when we’re nearly there. If I say it now, you’ll do something to the car.”
“I might.”
“I know.”
The silence that followed was thick enough to stand on. The wipers dragged across the glass in slow arcs. Julian’s hands were ten and two on the wheel, and he held them like a man who had been told, once, in a different life, that if he let go, the whole world would slide.
“Why now?” I said.
He glanced at me in the mirror. It was the first time he had looked at me directly since the lake house hall.
“Because he said her name like a bill,” Julian said. “Lucia. He said it the way you’d say a line item. And I thought, I’ve been a line item for twelve years, and I never once noticed the person doing the adding.”
“Twelve years,” Noah said.
“I was nineteen.” He turned onto a ramp. The road lifted onto a long bridge, wet and black and lit by sodium lamps that dyed the rain amber. “I’d been to a party. A girl had been hurt, a stupid, drunk accident on a staircase. It wasn’t my fault. It wasn’t. But I ran, and someone saw me run. By morning there was a folder with my name on it and a nice man in a gray suit sitting in my mother’s kitchen, explaining that he could make it vanish.”
“Thomas.”
“Thomas.” He laughed, a small, ugly sound. “He never asked for anything. That was the genius of it. He just remained. A kind man in the corner of my life, remembering my birthday, buying me cufflinks for my twenty-first. Silver, with blue stones. He said blue was the color of men who could be trusted.”
I looked at the square, undone links at his wrists, and a chill went through me.
“The girl on the staircase,” I said. “Did she live?”
“Yes.” He swallowed. “She’s a nurse now. In Ohio. I looked her up last winter.” A pause. “I was going to write to her.”
“Why didn’t you?”
“Because I’d have had to explain why I never did before.”
Noah turned his head. He studied Julian’s profile for a long moment, the clean line of the jaw, the nick on his chin where he’d shaved in a hurry, and something in his own face loosened, only slightly.
“That’s the first honest thing you’ve said to her,” he said.
“I know.”
“It doesn’t fix anything.”
“I know that too.”
The bridge ended. The city rose around us, low and gray, a warren of closed shops and shuttered garages. Julian slowed. I knew these streets before I knew I knew them. A bike shop on Delancey with its grate pulled down. A laundromat on the corner of Fifth. And ahead, two blocks off, a crooked row of old brick storefronts, dark except for one, where a sign hung by one hook over a door painted a faded, hopeful red.
I heard Noah stop breathing.
REYES FAMILY KITCHEN. The paint had flaked from the R. The window was boarded. A heavy padlock hung from the door, and above it, a notice in plain black letters: PROPERTY OF HARTWELL CAPITAL RECOVERY. NO ENTRY.
“No,” Noah said.
“It’s been empty for three years,” Julian said quietly. “Thomas uses the back. It has a cold room. Soundproofed, after the health inspection. He has a key.”
“My father built that cold room.”
“I know.”
“He built it with his hands. He cried when it passed inspection.” Noah’s voice was very low and very even. “And you put her in there.”
“I didn’t. I told him it existed. That’s worse. I know it’s worse.”
Julian stopped the car at the curb. Nobody moved. The engine ticked. Rain streamed down the windshield in long, even sheets, and the red door waited at the end of the block like a held breath.
“I need two minutes,” Noah said.
“We have five.”
“I need two.”
He got out. He walked a few steps down the pavement and stood with his back to us, in the rain, a long wet shape under the streetlight with his head bowed. I couldn’t hear him. I saw his shoulders move once, and then again, and then go still.
I got out and went to him.
I did not say anything. I stood beside him in the downpour and let it run into my collar, and after a while I slid my hand into his. His fingers were cold and rough and wet, and they closed over mine so tightly it hurt.
“I used to sleep in there,” he said, without looking at me. “In the dry storage. On flour sacks. When Dad worked double shifts and Mom was at the hospital. I was nine. I’d lie in the dark and listen to the walk-in compressor hum, and it was the safest sound in the world.” A breath. “That’s where she is. The safest sound in the world.”
“We’ll get her.”
“I know.”
“Noah.”
“I know.” He turned and looked at me, finally, and his face was wrecked and raw and very young. “I’m scared of what I’ll do when I see her.”
“What do you think you’ll do?”
“Something I can’t take back.”
“Then I’ll be there.” I tightened my hand. “I’ll be right there, saying your name, until you remember who you are.”
He laughed, broken. “You’d be terrible at that. You apologize too much.”
“I only apologize when I’ve already decided to do the opposite.”
For a heartbeat, in the rain, he really looked at me. The old careful curtain was gone. What stood behind it was a man who hadn’t been allowed to want anything in so long he had forgotten what it looked like.
“Ellie,” he said.
“Elena.”
“No.” A small, tired smile. “I think I like Ellie better. When it’s just us.”
My throat closed. I could not answer. I only nodded, and he lifted our joined hands, turned mine over, and pressed his mouth, very briefly, to the knuckle with the pale dent where the ring had sat too tight.
Then he let go.
We walked to the red door together. Julian stayed at the car with the engine on, as agreed. In my hand I held the drive, wrapped in a strip of lining torn from Walter’s coat, and in my other, the cold prepaid phone, still glowing, still ticking down.
The padlock hung open.
Noah looked at it. I looked at it. Neither of us said a word.
He pushed. The door swung inward with a long, soft groan, and a smell rolled out into the rain. Old flour. Cold stone. And under it, warm, absurd, impossible, the smell of cumin and lime and slow-cooked onion.
Someone had been cooking.
The front room was dark. But at the back, past the empty bar, a line of yellow light glowed under the kitchen door, and on the checkerboard floor, in the thin gold stripe of it, stood one small object, upright, deliberate, like a chess piece set down for a move.
A stapler.
Noah went down on one knee and picked it up. Taped to the side was a folded strip of ivory paper, ribbed along the edge, scented faintly with lavender. He opened it. I read it over his shoulder.
Four lines, in Thomas Wren’s neat, tidy hand.
She was never here. You were never meant to arrive in time. The real exchange is happening at the lake house, and your parents are alone with me.
Beneath it, smaller:
Do give my regards to Julian.
The phone in my hand shivered. Not a text from Noah this time. Not the nameless number. A new contact, saved by a girl who loved me enough to hide a goat in my life, and who had sent me exactly one word.
PRIYA: GOAT.