Chapter 2: A SMILE FOR TWO HUNDRED0% read • ~9 min

Chapter 2

A SMILE FOR TWO HUNDRED

9 min read•2,027 words

I put my shoes back on in the service corridor, one hand braced against a wall that was sweating with heat.

My feet had gone numb in the alley. The heels bit into them like punishment, and I welcomed it. Pain was simple. Pain had edges.

Noah had not walked me to the door. He’d held it open, said “Careful, the step’s loose,” and gone back to his sink without looking at me again. I told myself that was a relief. I had come out here to disappear, not to be seen, and a man who didn’t look back was exactly the kind of stranger you wanted.

So why did I keep my fingers on the cold steel of the door for a full three seconds after it closed?

I fixed my hair in the reflection of a pot rack. The woman looking back at me had smudged lipstick and the wide, startled eyes of someone caught stealing. I wiped the corner of my mouth with my thumb. I breathed in for four counts and out for six, the way a voice coach had taught me when I was fourteen and had to give my first toast at a gala.

Smile.

There she was. Elena Hartwell, returned to service.

The ballroom hit me like a wall of warm perfume. Two hundred people, laughing at the exact volume money laughs. Somebody had replaced the Vivaldi with a jazz trio, and the singer was crooning about moonlight to a room that hadn’t looked at the sky in years. I slipped in beside a pillar and took a glass of champagne off a passing tray, not because I wanted it but because a glass gave my hands something to do.

“There you are, darling.”

Julian materialized at my elbow. He did that. In eight months of dating I had never once seen him cross a room. He was simply elsewhere, and then he was beside me, smelling of cedar and expensive soap, his smile already in place.

“Powder room,” I said. “The line was endless.”

“Mm.” His eyes moved over my face, my hair, my shoes. “You’ve got a little something.”

He touched the corner of my jaw with one knuckle. It came away with a smear of cumin-orange grease. Staff meal. I had licked my fingers like a child and never once thought of a napkin.

My stomach dropped.

Julian looked at his knuckle for a long moment. Then he took out a pocket square, wiped it clean without a word, and tucked the cloth back into his jacket. He adjusted one cufflink, then the other.

“Gravy?” he said lightly.

“Canapé. Someone’s elbow.”

“Of course.” He smiled again. It didn’t touch his eyes, but it never did, and for months I had mistaken that for good manners. “Your father’s looking for you. He’s in the library. Go on, I’ll cover for you.”

“Cover what?”

“Your absence, darling. I told everyone you were overwhelmed by the attention.” His hand settled on my back, warm and proprietary. “It’s sweet. They love it.”

I wanted to ask who he had told, and what else he had noticed, and why he looked at me sometimes the way a man looks at a house he is about to buy. Instead I said, “Thank you,” and he kissed my temple, and I walked away while two hundred people watched me do it.

The library at the Hartwell Hotel was not really a library. Nobody had ever read any of the books. They were leather spines bought by the yard and arranged by color, and the room smelled of old cigars that no one had smoked since the nineties. My father stood at the window with his back to me, hands clasped behind him, a silver-haired outline against the rain.

“Close the door, Elena.”

I closed it. The noise from the ballroom dropped away as if someone had turned a dial.

He didn’t turn around. That was how I knew it was bad. My father only turned when he was angry, because anger needed an audience. Quiet disappointment he delivered to windows.

“Fourteen minutes,” he said.

“I needed air.”

“You left your own engagement toast.” He said it gently. He said everything gently. When I was nine he had told me my mother’s funeral would be small and private, in exactly this voice, and I’d thought for a week that it was a kindness. “Two hundred people were watching you walk away.”

“I came back.”

“You did.” He turned then, finally, and his face was perfectly calm. Richard Hartwell had a face built for rooms with long tables. Lean, clean-shaven, eyes the color of weak tea. “The head of security tells me you went through the kitchen.”

Something small and cold turned over in my chest.

“I got lost.”

“In a hotel your family owns.”

“It’s a big hotel.”

“It’s a large hotel with excellent signage.” He walked to the desk and picked up a gold pen, the same one he’d used on the champagne glass. He rolled it between his thumb and forefinger. “I am not angry, Elena. I want you to hear that. I understand nerves. Your mother was the same before our wedding. She locked herself in a coat closet for an hour.” A small, fond smile. “She came out and she was fine.”

It was the first time he had mentioned her in fifteen years without being asked, and I felt it go through me like a hook.

“Dad,” I said. “What was she like? Before.”

The smile vanished. Not dramatically. It simply was not there anymore, like a light on a timer.

“We are discussing tonight,” he said.

“I know. But you just said she—”

“Julian is a good man,” my father continued, as if I hadn’t spoken. “He is patient. He understands what this family is and what it requires. I would not have chosen him for you otherwise.” He set the pen down, precisely parallel to the edge of the blotter. “You will go back out there. You will dance with him. You will smile at the Hendersons and the Marlowes and everyone who matters, and tomorrow we will not speak of the kitchen. Is that clear?”

It was a question in the way a closed door was a question.

“Yes,” I said.

“Good girl.”

I hated how it landed. I hated that some starved animal in my chest still wagged its tail.

He crossed to me and kissed my forehead, dry and brief, a stamp on an envelope. At the door he paused.

“One more thing. Security mentioned that the kitchen staff are not supposed to leave the back entrance unattended during events. I have asked for a review of who was on shift.” A pause. “I’m sure it’s nothing. I only mention it so you know how seriously I take your safety.”

My hand tightened on the doorframe.

“It was my fault,” I said. “Nobody did anything. I wandered in.”

“Then there will be nothing to find.”

He smiled at me, and left me alone among the unread books.

I don’t remember the next hour. I remember a dance with Julian during which I counted the beads on a woman’s dress over his shoulder. I remember laughing at a joke from a man whose name I forgot as he said it. I remember a waiter passing with a tray of tiny crab cakes and thinking, with a violence that startled me: somebody downstairs washed the plate that held that.

At twelve forty, Priya found me.

She came through the crowd like a tugboat through a regatta, five feet two inches of black velvet and unapologetic elbows, her hair twisted up with a pencil because she’d lost her hairpin and refused to be defeated. She grabbed my wrist and steered me bodily into a coat room smelling of wet wool.

“Okay,” she said. “Fourteen missing minutes, Julian saying you had a panic attack, your father doing his sad statue impression by the stairs, and you’ve been smiling like a hostage for an hour. What happened?”

“Nothing.”

“Elena.”

“I went outside. I ate something. I came back.”

“Ate something.” Priya’s eyebrows climbed. “You haven’t eaten since spring. Where did you eat something?”

“The kitchen.”

“You ate in the kitchen.”

“Out the back. In the alley. Someone gave me rice.” I heard myself and winced. “Don’t make that face.”

“I am not making a face. This is my regular face, which is, for the record, delighted.” She put both hands on my shoulders and examined me with narrowed eyes. “Was it a man? It was a man. You have the look.”

“What look?”

“The one where you pretend you’re upset but your whole face is lit up like a Christmas tree in a blackout.”

“It’s not a look. It was a dishwasher. He gave me dinner and a lecture about trash compactors, and I told him my name was Ellie.”

Priya went very still.

“Ellie,” she said. “You gave a stranger the name nobody’s called you since your mother.”

I opened my mouth. Closed it.

I had not realized. Ellie was my mother’s name for me. It lived in a handful of memories like single frames of film. A yellow kitchen. Flour on my nose. A voice singing in the next room while I pretended to nap. No one had said it to me in fifteen years, and I had handed it to a man in an alley as if it were a spare napkin.

“It just came out,” I said.

“Mm-hm.” Priya’s face softened. She pulled me into a brief hard hug that smelled of vanilla and hairspray. “Okay. Here’s what we do. You go home tonight. You sleep. You do not text him, because you don’t have his number, and you do not go looking for him, because you are engaged and your father would have the man’s fingerprints removed.”

“I know.”

“And if you do go looking, I get details.”

“Priya.”

“I’m only being practical.”

I laughed, but it hurt.

We stayed until the last of the guests drifted out into the rain. Julian kissed my cheek at the curb and said, “Wonderful night, darling,” and I said, “Yes,” and watched the taillights of his car recede down the glistening street. My father’s driver held the door for me. I climbed in and sat with my hands folded over a ring that no longer felt like jewelry. It felt like a handcuff someone had tailored to fit.

The city slid past the window in streaks of gold and red. I watched drops race each other down the glass, and I thought about a milk crate, and a laugh I hadn’t known I had, and a man who had looked at me like a person and then, one second later, like a problem.

What had he seen on his phone? Why had he gone so still at my name?

Wrong number, he’d said. I had grown up among liars so skilled that their lies came with matching napkins. Noah Reyes was not one of them. He was clumsy at it. His voice had gone flat. His thumb had pressed so hard against the screen that his nail turned white.

The car turned onto my street. The gates opened. The house waited at the end of the drive with every window lit, a ship nobody had ever sailed.

My phone buzzed in my clutch.

I almost ignored it. Priya, I thought. Or Julian, sending something sweet and rehearsed.

But the number on the screen was one I had never seen before. No name. No photo. Just a string of digits and a single message beneath it, short enough to fit on the lock screen.

Come back tomorrow, Ellie.

I read it once. Then again.

I had never given anyone my number tonight. Not Noah. Not the man in the black apron. Not a single soul in that kitchen.

And only two people on earth had ever called me Ellie. One of them had been dead for fifteen years.

The other had sat across from me in an alley a few hours ago, and told me his name was Noah.